Home Union-busting constitutional amendment fails in Senate
News and Views

Union-busting constitutional amendment fails in Senate

AFP

state-capitol2Senate Republicans failed on Tuesday to approve a constitutional amendment that openly conflicts with federal law. The vote was 20-17, with all Democrats opposed. (Constitutional amendments require twenty-one votes in order to pass; one Republican senator did not vote.) Under the guise of protecting Virginians’ ability to vote by secret ballot, Sen. Bryce Reeves’ (R – Spotsylvania) SJ 278 would have prohibited a federally-protected means of organizing a union.

Said Sen. Donald McEachin (D – Henrico), “SJ 278 would put our state constitution into direct conflict with federal law. Instead of wasting time on such a cheap political stunt, Republicans should be working with us to enact common-sense solutions that help Virginians lead safer, healthier, and more prosperous lives.”

Said Sen. John Edwards (D – Roanoke), “We already have the secret ballot in the political process, as we should, but this resolution also applies to labor unions. Federal law pre-empts this amendment as it applies to organized labor, because labor relations are covered by the National Labor Relations Act. Passing a Virginia constitutional amendment on this issue would violate the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution.”

Under the National Labor Relations Act, unions can be formed by either a secret ballot or a card check process. If employers wish to contest the result of a card check, they can require that it be ratified by secret ballot — but if they wish to accept the result and move on, they have that right, as well. If all union organizing efforts were required to include a secret ballot, employers would lose that option.

 

Support AFP

Newsletter

Featured Video

 




AFP

AFP

Have a guest column, letter to the editor, story idea or a news tip? Email editor Chris Graham at [email protected]. Subscribe to AFP podcasts on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Pandora and YouTube. Support AFP by signing up for our newsletter and/or powering our work with a one-time or monthly contribution.

Latest News

James Franklin Virginia Tech
Sports News & Views

‘Big Game James’: Virginia Tech blows early 14-0 lead, falls at #7 Miami, 28-20

uva football beau pribula
Football

UVA Football: Elliott, ‘Hoos finally get things right, just, unfortunately, too late

I don’t know that UVA Football coach Tony Elliott should be taking a victory lap for finally getting his team right as the season is winding down, given that the Virginia team that we’ve seen the past two weeks is the one that I thought we’d see all season.

school bus arm
Local

Waynesboro School Board set to name next school superintendent on Monday

The Waynesboro School Board appears to be set on who it will put in place as the next superintendent of Waynesboro Public Schools.

da'shawn martin td
Football

UVA Football: How did the ‘Hoos give up 581 yards and still dominate UNC?

uva football
Football

UVA Football: ‘Hoos wallop North Carolina, 41-24, to win home finale

westwood hills elementary school
Local

Source: 911 call warned of suspicious person ahead of Westwood Hills shooting

lynchburg
Virginia

No charges to be filed in death of Lynchburg man being detained by police