Home Bad idea, revisited: McMahon announces 2020 return for XFL
Football

Bad idea, revisited: McMahon announces 2020 return for XFL

Chris Graham

xflVince McMahon confirmed weeks of speculation Thursday, announcing the return of a curiously gimmick-free, and likely also talent- and entertainment-value-free, XFL in 2020.

McMahon, the chairman of World Wrestling Entertainment, said in announcing the return of the pro football league, which operated for one season, in 2001, before shutting its doors as a $70 million loss for McMahon and broadcast partner NBC, that he will be the sole source of funding for the venture, which might be the first indication to its lack of long-term viability.

The plans are for an eight-team league, with 40-man active rosters and a 10-week regular season that would conclude with playoffs consisting of two semifinal games and a championship game.

The initial outlay for the league is expected to be around $100 million, roughly the value of the stock in WWE that McMahon sold last month to seed Alpha Entertainment, the company that he founded for the project.

The announcement was light on business plans and heavy on aesthetics, such as the running time for games – McMahon, constantly under fire from wrestling fans for the three-hour-plus run time for WWE’s flagship weekly TV show, “Monday Night Raw,” said the ideal running time for XFL games will be around two hours.

“We aren’t going to have much of what the XFL had, including the cheerleaders, who aren’t really part of the game anymore. The audience wants entertainment with football, and that’s what we are going to give them,” McMahon told ESPN.

Just how much entertainment value the new XFL will be able to offer fans is the big question. Even with gimmicks like the opening scramble, no fair catches and unlimited bump-and-run coverage, and the cheerleaders dressed like strippers on the sidelines, the original XFL failed due to the abysmally poor product on the field.

With $100 million to play with for the whole operation, you’re looking at roughly 60 percent of the single-year salary cap for a single NFL team, and that’s not even accounting for the dollars that the XFL will have to outlay for support personnel, facility rental, TV production and various and sundry other line items.

Another way to put that: the XFL is not going to feature a single player who has even a sliver of a chance of playing in the NFL.

Here’s how you can guarantee this will be the case: in addition to the fact that the league will be severely undercapitalized just in general, McMahon’s grand idea for dealing with player salaries is to have them hinge on wins and losses.

“To me that’s common sense,” McMahon told ESPN. “Everyone in America lives when they perform, they get a raise or bonus. That’s capitalism.”

Actually, capitalism is more about business models working or not working, McMahon seems to think that giving the new XFL a two-year startup phase is the most important feature in terms of determining its potential for success.

The focus for the next year will apparently be on the production and broadcast rights sides of the ledger, with rosters coming into shape, such as you can say that with a straight face, in 2019.

The NFL has nothing to worry about. To be blunt about it, Arena Football has nothing to worry about.

Story by Chris Graham

Support AFP




Chris Graham

Chris Graham

Chris Graham is the founder and editor of Augusta Free Press. A 1994 alum of the University of Virginia, Chris is the author and co-author of seven books, including Poverty of Imagination, a memoir published in 2019. For his commentaries on news, sports and politics, go to his YouTube page, TikTok, BlueSky, or subscribe to Substack or his Street Knowledge podcast. Email Chris at [email protected].

Latest News

social media twitter X data
U.S. & World

Rareness bias diffusion: Virginia Tech research explains our social media fix

kyle johnson uva baseball
Baseball

UVA Baseball: Kyle Johnson signs with Tampa Bay, updates on other draft picks

Kyle Johnson, a weekend starting pitcher and power-hitting outfielder with the UVA Baseball team in 2026, has signed with the Tampa Bay Rays, who had taken him in the sixth round of the 2026 MLB Draft.

uva basketball huddle
Basketball

UVA Basketball: How our three Virginia alums fared in the 2026 NBA Summer League

The 2026 NBA Summer League is over and done with – yep, goes by fast – and we saw some good work put in by three UVA Basketball alums with their summer teams.

swimming
Etc.

Charlottesville: Why does it cost $25,000 to host a local swim meet?

Monzerath Tenorio Aidan Rodriguez
Local

Spanberger appoints Waynesboro High School senior to state advisory board

Norfolk Virginia
Virginia

Norfolk: One person dead in Interstate 264 shooting on Tuesday morning

flock License plate reader police
Local

Community group persuades Elkton Town Council to cut ties with Flock