jump to example.com

Andrew Dobelstein: Keep Social Security off the table

money-newlinksPresident Obama’s proposal to restrict the growth of Social Security by changing annual cost-of-living adjustments (COLAs) from the present Consumer Price Index (CPI) to a Chained Consumer Price Index represents a disingenuous departure from his earlier position to hold fast on Social Security. Such a proposal itself would have little effect on either Social Security benefits or on the long-term Social Security Trust Fund needed to satisfy future beneficiary claims. The Congressional Budget Office recently estimated that a chained CPI (CPI/U) “would increase, on average, by 3 percentage points more slowly per year than will the existing CPI,” and that Social Security’s total outlays would “decline by 4 percent, from currently scheduled outlays.” This option, CBO estimated, would improve the 75-year trust fund balance by only 0.2 percentage points of GDP and would extend the trust fund exhaustion date by four years at the most. (CBO, 2010)

The real hazard in the president’s proposal comes from Including Social Security in deficit reduction negotiations for at least two reasons. First, Social Security is not part of the deficit. In fact, it may be the only federal program with a surplus in its Trust Fund. Clearly, there have been confusions about how to account for surpluses in the fund. Congress approved the use of a “unified” budget by including Social Security Trust Fund operations in the 1974 budget process, and accounting for Social Security taxing, spending and its reserves has bounced back and forth: off-budget from 1935-1968; on-budget from 1969-1985; off-budget from 1986-1990, for all purposes except computing the deficit; and off-budget for all purposes since 1990. Even before President Bush proposed “privatizing” Social Security, Republican lawmakers have been trying to appropriate these government-held funds.

There is a second, more compelling danger from the president’s proposal to change the COLA. Such a proposal only confuses and compounds Social Security’s long-range problem. Social Security is solvent for at least 20 years under current legislation, but the growing number of beneficiaries on the one hand, and the shrinking number of workers relative to Social Security beneficiaries will only continue to exacerbate Social Security’s long-range problems. Ever since its beginning, financing Social Security has been controversial, and over the years Congress has agreed to incremental changes in its financial and benefit structure, only to discover that additional incremental changes quickly are needed. President Obama’s willingness to include Social Security in debt negotiations simply re-opens longstanding funding disputes before there is sufficient intelligence available to guide a debate over the present nature of Social Security and how it must be financed.

We need to keep in mind that today Social Security provides financial benefit to more 50 million people, over 18 percent of the population, that only 70 percent of those beneficiaries are retired workers, that more children receive Social Security payments than children who receive public welfare, and that Social Security’s redistributive formula has kept 40 percent of the elderly who would otherwise be poor out of poverty. Social Security is no longer our grandmother’s retirement program. It has become a comprehensive social insurance program, and until this reality is seriously explored, politically expedient proposals like changing the COLA are useless and damage Social Security’s credibility. A changed CPI? Dangerous political candy.

Andrew Dobelstein, Ph.D. is Professor Emeritus of Social Welfare at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

Discussion
 
Top News
 
a

Virginia House passes bill to loosen gun safety rules in foster homes

The House of Delegates passed a bill to remove safety requirements surrounding the storage of guns by individuals caring for foster children.

Street Knowledge with Chris Graham: Seven new planets in the neighborhood

Chris Graham talks with Virginia Tech professor Scott King about the NASA announcement of seven earth-like planets 39 light-years away.

Survey: What do Waynesboro residents think?

Residents think Waynesboro is a good place to live, raise children and retire, and that the city does a good job with police, fire and rescue.

Waynesboro High School student arrested for threats

The Waynesboro Police Department has charged a 16-year-old for communicating threats to Waynesboro High School.

Salvation Army thrift store closing: Tough decision, but right one

The Waynesboro Salvation Army thrift store on Arch Avenue has been consistently losing money in recent years.

Three trends to watch in the 2017 real estate market

Nobody has a crystal ball to know exactly what the future holds for the real estate market.

Fishburne Military School announces MacArthur Award Winner

Fishburne Military School announced the recipient of the 2017 General Douglas MacArthur Award for Leadership.

Augusta County man charged in weekend gun incident in Waynesboro

The Waynesboro Police Department has charged an Augusta County man after an early Saturday morning altercation erupted in gunfire near a city restaurant.

McAuliffe vetoes bill defunding Planned Parenthood

Governor Terry McAuliffe vetoed a bill that would restrict state and federal funding for women’s health providers like Planned Parenthood.

Fishburne Military School wrestlers advance to national championships

The Fishburne Military School wrestling team had an exceptional weekend at the VISAA State Wrestling Tournament.

 
Recent News
 

Your One-Stop Media Shop

Augusta Free Press LLC provides clients in the Shenandoah Valley and Central Virginia and beyond with marketing and PR solutions including web design, magazine/brochure, TV/radio, social media and overall marketing campaign design and implementation.
  • Web Design

    You want a new website, but don’t have the first clue as to how to build one. That’s our job. We take care of all facets of web design – visual design, layout design and content development. Get your business online for as little as $1,299.
    Learn more about AFP Web Design services.
  • Graphic Design

    The staff at Augusta Free Press Publishing has been recognized by the Virginia Press Association for excellence in layout and design. Whether you need a fresh business card design, rack card, ad, flyer or full magazine design, we can help with all your graphic-design needs.
    Learn more about AFP Graphic Design services.
  • Marketing

    Augusta Free Press manages advertising campaigns for small- and medium-sized businesses across Virginia. You don’t need to hire a full-time marketing coordinator. Bring the experience of the Augusta Free Press team to work for you – for a fraction of the cost.
    Learn more about AFP Marketing services.