
In a letter dated March 9, ACLU-VA Executive Director Claire Guthrie Gastañaga called the bill “an unusual and inappropriate intervention into the routine operations of public schools” that “constitutes a content-based regulation of speech that should be rejected as a threat to the First Amendment.”
The bill, sponsored by Del. R. Steven Landes (R-Verona), would require the state Board of Education to develop a policy by which parents would be notified of explicit content and have the option to request an alternate assignment for their children.
“Passing judgments, applying labels and red-flagging educational materials that might prompt uncomfortable but insightful discussions is a small-minded activity that does not belong in public schools, state Board of Education policy or Virginia law,” the ACLU-VA’s letter continues.
Further, the bill conflicts with Article VIII Section 7 of the Virginia Constitution that gives local school boards “primary responsibility and authority for effectuating the educational policy” outlined in the constitution.
The ACLU-VA’s position is in support of the National Coalition Against Censorship, eight members of which signed onto aseparate letter asking the governor to veto HB516.