Home The JD Vance immigrants-eating-pets lie was based on a cat found hiding in the basement
Virginia

The JD Vance immigrants-eating-pets lie was based on a cat found hiding in the basement

Chris Graham
jd vance
(© Phil Mistry – Shutterstock)

JD Vance based his telling of the lie that Haitian immigrants in Springfield, Ohio, were stealing and eating pets on a single debunked police report from a Trump supporter.

And get this: that lady’s cat, which, according to her police report, she suspected had been taken by Haitian immigrant neighbors, had not actually gone missing.

“I had no idea where she was, but she never left the house,” the woman, identified by the Wall Street Journal as Anna Kilgore, told a reporter, admitting that the cat, Miss Sassy, had been found hiding in her basement.

Well, don’t that beat all.

I mean, you know, cats will be cats.

What a cute story.

Well, except for the part about it involving a Trump supporter just assuming that her “missing” cat had been taken and eaten by the black immigrant people next door.


ICYMI


It was this lone police report that the Trump-Vance campaign cited in response to a request from the Journal for evidence backing the claims of the Republican ticket about Haitian immigrants, which both Trump and Vance continue to stand behind.

The immigrants-eating-pets stories have been tracked to a woman posting to a private Facebook group with a fourth-hand telling, which was picked up by a neo-Nazi blogger.

The woman behind the original Facebook post, identified as Erika Lee, is now using the “I’m not a racist” defense, and claims that she has pulled her daughter out of school out of concerns for her safety.

Her sob story there rings hollow against the backdrop of the MAGA-fueled bomb threats that have closed schools, government buildings and hospitals in Springfield, because the MAGAs are upset that city officials aren’t feeding into the narrative about pet-eating immigrants that Trump and Vance are continuing to try to sell, in the face of what have to be embarrassing fact-checks from all corners.

That the obviously false stories reached the presidential-race level is due to the utter gullibility of Trump, who, in response to a dig from Vice President Kamala Harris in their Sept. 10 ABC News debate about his boring campaign rallies, shouted into the ether:

“In Springfield, they’re eating the dogs, the people that came in, they’re eating the cats, they’re eating, they’re eating the pets of the people that live there, and this is what’s happening in our country, and it’s a shame.”

It’s notable that, a day earlier, a Vance campaign aide had reached out to the city manager in Springfield, Bryan Heck, to ask “point-blank, Are the rumors true of pets being taken and eaten?”

Heck recounted the phone call in an interview with the Wall Street Journal, which noted that his response was “unequivocal.

“I told him no, there was no verifiable evidence or reports to show this was true,” Heck said.

Basically, they knew, and went with the lie anyway, and the result of that is, they’ve shut down a city of 58,106 people for a week, or until the next nonsense lie gets their people who call in bomb threats to focus their attention elsewhere.

Video: Hey, JD, the cat was found in the basement


Support AFP




Chris Graham

Chris Graham

Chris Graham is the founder and editor of Augusta Free Press. A 1994 alum of the University of Virginia, Chris is the author and co-author of seven books, including Poverty of Imagination, a memoir published in 2019. For his commentaries on news, sports and politics, go to his YouTube page, TikTok, BlueSky, or subscribe to Substack or his Street Knowledge podcast. Email Chris at [email protected].

Latest News

vdot road construction
Local

VDOT: Updated road work scheduled for the week of July 6-10

Donald Trump FIFA Peace Prize
Etc.

Trump called FIFA president to get reversal on suspension: The bloom is off the USMNT rose

We’ve now officially entered the U.S. is cheating! phase of the 2026 World Cup, with word that Donald Trump personally appealed to FIFA President Gianni Infantino to lobby for a reversal of the one-game suspension for USMNT star Folarin Balogun.

charlottesville map
Local

Charlottesville: Updates for road work ongoing the week of July 6-10

The Charlottesville Department of Utilities is kicking off Phase I of the West Main Street Utilities Replacement Project on Monday, July 6.

fair carnival flag ferris wheel fireworks circus tent election
U.S. & World

Alon Ben-Meir: America at 250 faces a reckoning, and a call to conscience

staunton
Local

Staunton: John Glover retires as city building official after 31 years with local government

radio
Local

Last Week in Rob Schilling: The point has been made, so, time to move on

Folarin Balogun
Etc.

World Cup: USMNT gets leading goal scorer back in shock FIFA move