Home Ivan Sascha Sheehan | Virginia should not rush the NextEra-Dominion merger
Virginia

Ivan Sascha Sheehan | Virginia should not rush the NextEra-Dominion merger

Ivan Sascha Sheehan
power grid electricity
Photo: © yelantsevv/stock.adobe.com

The Virginia State Corporation Commission review of the proposed NextEra-Dominion merger should begin with the basic commonwealth premise that public authority exists to serve the common good.

As one of four commonwealth states, Virginia has traditions that reflect the conviction that government is not merely an umpire between private parties but charged with protecting shared interests when private decisions carry public consequences.

That tradition matters – and as a former Virginia resident, George Mason University alumnus, and now a public policy professor, I have an interest.

The Dominion-NextEra proposal should be evaluated as more than a utility merger because this deal sits at the intersection of two forces reshaping Virginia’s future: electric utility consolidation and data-center demand.

Dominion is already central to Northern Virginia’s data-center economy, the largest such market in the world. Electric utilities such as Dominion occupy a distinct place in American economic life. They are private companies, but they operate under public privileges. Their customers often have no practical market substitute. Their rates, infrastructure plans, and service decisions affect households, employers, hospitals, schools, military installations, and local governments.

In exchange for monopoly characteristics and regulated returns, utilities accept obligations that go beyond shareholder value.

Data centers support cloud computing, artificial intelligence, national competitiveness, and the digital economy. They are important assets. But they also require vast amounts of electricity, new transmission capacity, land-use approvals, tax policy accommodations, and long-term infrastructure planning. Their growth is forcing states to confront difficult questions about cost allocation, reliability, permitting, and who ultimately pays for grid expansion.

If approved, the transaction would create the world’s largest regulated electric utility business with substantial influence over generation, transmission, reliability planning, rate proceedings, clean-energy compliance, and the infrastructure needed to serve large new loads. In Virginia, that influence would be exercised in a market where data centers already shape electricity demand and public policy.

Florida-based NextEra arrives with a record of legal controversies, including allegations involving political consulting firms, so-called ghost candidates, media influence campaigns, and other tactics designed to shape public debate. While NextEra has denied these claims and deserves a fair review on the merits, the question becomes whether democratic institutions can protect the public interest when essential infrastructure, monopoly power, and politically sophisticated actors converge.

The combination of political power centers represented by this proposed merger is a test of whether public-interest obligations can prevail on private infrastructure giants where big power and big data are converging.

The core governance questions are unavoidable: who benefits, who pays, and who decides? The NextEra-Dominion merger should be reviewed in that context.

Regulators need not treat denied allegations as established fact to recognize their relevance. A public utility regulator is not conducting a trial. It is assessing fitness, risk, public benefit, and the long-term interests of customers. Serious allegations about political influence, hidden attribution, media operations, and consultant-directed pressure campaigns are relevant to an assessment of whether such a company should be granted greater control over essential infrastructure.

Virginia does not need a less than transparent or rushed review. It needs a serious one.

Data centers will remain central to the state’s economy. Utilities will remain essential to growth, reliability, and decarbonization. But when big power and big data converge, public institutions must be capable of protecting the people who cannot negotiate their own terms: families, small businesses, workers, and communities.

Virginia’s current process appears poorly matched to the scale of the decision. The SCC has only 180 days to conduct its review and Virginia’s legal standard does not require the companies to prove the merger is good for Virginians or that rates will not rise. A passive standard is unequal to the SCC mission and the test that the proposed merger represents.

In a commonwealth, the public interest is not a secondary consideration. It is the standard by which a merger of this type should be evaluated.

 

Support AFP

Newsletter

Featured Video

 

 




Ivan Sascha Sheehan

Ivan Sascha Sheehan

Ivan Sascha Sheehan is the interim dean of the College of Public Affairs at the University of Baltimore, where he is a professor of public and international affairs. Follow him on X @ProfSheehan.

Latest News

ben cline
Politics, Virginia

Ben Cline announces series of town halls, with a catch, in the form of a waitlist

waynesboro map
Local

Waynesboro PD still mum on Sept. 2 school shooting: Do we need to fire somebody over this?

Waynesboro Police are, still, not answering questions about the Sept. 2 shooting at Westwood Hills Elementary School, in which a former student took his own life in the school library.

measles illustration
Local

Virginia Department of Health confirms local measles case, warns of possible exposure

The Virginia Department of Health is investigating potential measles exposures to people who were at UVA Health University Medical Center in Charlottesville and Centra Southside Community Hospital in Farmville in the past couple of days.

suicide death mental health depression candle
Local

A father writes about his daughter’s death by suicide: Don’t let the conversation end

uva nov 13 graphic
Football, Go 'Hoos

The Nov. 13 Record: UVA alumni group sheds light on what the school knew

uva football kam robinson INT
Football, Go 'Hoos

ACC Football: UVA linebacker Kam Robinson among the Players of the Week

ncaa
Go 'Hoos, Sports

Women’s Soccer: Virginia to host Bryant in NCAA Tournament on Friday