Home Judge denies motion to dismiss NASCAR antitrust suit; trial scheduled for December
NASCAR, Sports

Judge denies motion to dismiss NASCAR antitrust suit; trial scheduled for December

Rod Mullins
michael jordan nascar
(© Grindstone Media Group – Shutterstock)

The ongoing antitrust lawsuit filed by NASCAR teams 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports saw a major shift following a recent ruling in U.S. District Court.

U.S. District Court Judge Kenneth Bell rejected NASCAR’s motion to dismiss the lawsuit. The ruling allows the case to proceed toward trial, scheduled for Dec. 1, 2025. Bell declined NASCAR’s request to mandate the teams post a bond for earnings they receive in 2025 that might be repayable if the case resolves in NASCAR’s favor.

Judge Bell clarified that it remains unclear whether NASCAR violated antitrust laws, emphasizing that the issues require further discovery and jury deliberation. NASCAR contended that defining the market solely as Cup racing is overly narrow, arguing that its increased revenue sharing and 2025 charter agreements reflect competitive practices.

23XI and FRM assert that NASCAR’s actions, including limiting charters, violate antitrust regulations by stifling competition.

Bell indicated his intent to proceed swiftly with the trial, noting, “This case is going to be tried this year and deserves to be tried this year.”

In the meantime, Judge Bell issued two injunctions compelling NASCAR to allow 23XI and FRM to operate as three-charter organizations in 2025. This decision enforces the approval of charters purchased by both teams from Stewart-Haas Racing.

The denial of NASCAR’s motion to dismiss highlights the case’s complexity and the legal uncertainty surrounding antitrust issues in professional racing.

Judge Bell’s rulings suggest the court’s interest in a thorough examination of competitive practices within NASCAR, potentially setting a precedent for future disputes in the sport.

Rod Mullins

Rod Mullins

Rod Mullins covers NASCAR for AFP, the co-host of the “Street Knowledge” focusing on NASCAR with AFP editor Chris Graham, and is the editor of Dickenson Media. A graduate of UVA-Wise, Rod began his career in journalism as a reporter for The Cumberland Times, later became the program director/news director/on-air morning show host for WNVA in Norton, Va., and in the early 1990s served as the sports information director at UVA-Wise and was the radio “Voice of the Highland Cavaliers” for football and basketball for seven seasons. In 1995, Rod transitioned to public education, where he has worked as a high school English, literature, and creative writing teacher and now serves as a school program coordinator in addition to serving as a mentor for the robotics team.