Home Staunton approves certificate for Stonewall Jackson Hotel sign removal
News and Views

Staunton approves certificate for Stonewall Jackson Hotel sign removal

AFP

stauntonStaunton Zoning Administrator Rodney Rhodes has approved a certificate of appropriateness to remove the neon sign that sits on the Stonewall Jackson Hotel’s main rooftop.

In reaching the decision to issue the certificate, the zoning administrator was guided by the city’s long-established practice for city staff to review and administratively act on COA applications for signs in the city’s historic districts without submission to the entire Historic Preservation Commission, as permitted by the Staunton City Code.

Staff did make members of the City’s Historic Preservation Commission aware of the application.

It also is a matter of practice that staff invite the external expert input when considering applications. In this case, Frank Strassler, an expert in historic preservation with the Historic Staunton Foundation, as part of the established process analyzed the application and submitted a written briefing and recommendation before Rhodes acted on the application and approved the COA.

Based on his review and analysis, Strassler noted the following regarding the significance of the sign:

  • While the current sign is prominent in contemporary local memory, it is relatively new compared to the history of the hotel and the historic district. Architecturally, the sign does not reflect or relate the overall design and significance of the historic building or district.
  • The sign was not constructed during a period of significance for the historic district. With remnants of the 18th century and early to mid-19th century, the majority of downtown architecture reflects a period of prosperity between the 1870s through the 1920s.
  • The roof top sign dates to the early 1960s, when Downtown Staunton experienced a well-documented period of decline through Urban Renewal demolition, and with attempts to modernize storefronts. Modernization included metal façade coverings, boarding over windows, installing cement stucco awnings, and overuse of internally lighted signage in an attempt to compete with the look of new business construction at the outskirts of the community.

Strassler recommended that the COA be approved for the removal of the roof-top mounted neon sign and steel support structure, noting:

  • The sign type, location, and size do not reflect the adopted guidelines for the Beverley Historic District.
  • Upon review of the historical accounts, photographic record, and review of the architectural design of the 1925 hotel, the sign is not significant as a historic sign for its age and in relation to the overall architectural importance of the historic hotel building and historic district.

In addition, Rhodes determined the existing sign to be a nonconforming structure in that it does not conform to the zoning regulations of the applicable zoning district.  Roof-mounted signs and signs with exposed bulbs or external illumination are prohibited in the Business District, the zoning district in which the hotel is located.

The issuance of a COA does not confer approval from any other local, state or federal authority that may have jurisdiction in the matter. And it does not address anything other than the removal within the context of the historic preservation provisions of the Staunton City Code.

 

Support AFP

Newsletter

Featured Video

 

 




AFP

AFP

Have a guest column, letter to the editor, story idea or a news tip? Email editor Chris Graham at [email protected]. Subscribe to AFP podcasts on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Pandora and YouTube. Support AFP by signing up for our newsletter and/or powering our work with a one-time or monthly contribution.

Latest News

ben cline
Politics, Virginia

Update: Ben Cline announces more town halls, with more waitlists

National Christmas Tree
Local

Highland County red spruce selected to serve as National Christmas Tree

A tree from the mountains of Highland County has been selected to serve as the National Christmas Tree, for display on the mess that serves as the White House grounds, with construction going on everywhere because our president wants to build monuments to himself.

school bus arm
Local

Albemarle County schools closed because of another major administrative screwup

More than 500 people hired in the past three years to work for Albemarle County Public Schools were not checked against the Child Protective Services Central Registry.

newspaper online news AFP mobile phone newsfeed
Local

AFP needs to do more: Just warning you, we’re going to ask for your help to get there

uva central grounds
Football, Go 'Hoos

Conservative alums lead the fight to hold UVA accountable for the failures of Nov. 13

mobile games casino phone computer
Politics, Virginia

State AGs pushing Trump FCC to take real steps to get rid of annoying robocalls

uva basketball thijs de ridder
Basketball, Go 'Hoos

UVA Basketball: NBA-like early schedule, tempo, defense, Gertrude/de Ridder