By David Fox
Ask Google who invented the slot machine and you’ll get a tidy answer: Charles Fey, San Francisco, around 1895. Case closed, right?
Well. Not quite. The more I dug into this story, the more it started reading like a detective novel with three suspects, a destroyed crime scene, and a verdict that depends entirely on what you mean by “slot machine.” It’s genuinely one of the best origin stories in entertainment history, so let’s do it properly — suspect by suspect.
Suspect one: two guys from Brooklyn, 1891
Four years before Fey’s famous machine, the Brooklyn firm of Sittman and Pitt built a gambling device that swept New York bars. It held five drums with fifty playing cards, you dropped a nickel, pulled the lever, and tried to land a poker hand. By the mid-1890s these machines were reportedly in hundreds of bars across the city.
So why doesn’t Gustav Sittman get the Wikipedia crown? Two reasons, and they matter. The machine couldn’t pay out — a winning hand earned you a beer or cigars from the bartender, at his discretion, which made every payout a negotiation. And the odds were quietly rigged in the most analog way imaginable: operators typically removed two cards from the deck, the ten of spades and the jack of hearts, cutting the chance of a royal flush roughly in half. Fifty cards, not fifty-two. Hardly anyone noticed.
Verdict: inventors of the slot machine cabinet, maybe. Not the slot machine.
Suspect two: the Bavarian mechanic who actually did it
Charles August Fey was born in 1862 in Vöhringen, Bavaria, the youngest of sixteen children — sixteen! — and left home as a teenager, working through France and England before landing in San Francisco, where he took a job building scientific instruments. Tuberculosis nearly killed him in his twenties. Instead, he survived, and sometime around 1895 the trained instrument-maker built a cast-iron machine with three reels and five symbols, including a cracked Liberty Bell.
What made it the invention wasn’t the reels. It was the automatic payout mechanism — line up three bells, and the machine itself dropped ten nickels into the tray, no bartender required. Fey solved the exact problem that sank Sittman and Pitt: reading a three-reel result mechanically was possible where reading a five-card poker hand wasn’t. Simplify the game, and the machine can pay. That one insight is the whole industry.
Fey never patented it, by the way. Gambling devices occupied a legal grey zone, and he preferred renting his machines to saloons for a 50/50 split of the take — arguably inventing the slot route business too.
The plot twist that keeps historians up at night
Here’s where it gets properly messy. On April 18, 1906, the San Francisco earthquake and fire destroyed Fey’s workshop along with most of his records. Precisely dating the Liberty Bell became impossible — sources scatter between 1895 and 1899, and the machine’s early history is reconstructed from trade ads, newspaper fragments, and family memory.
And into that documentation gap steps suspect three: Herbert Mills, a Chicago manufacturer who in 1907 began mass-producing the Mills Liberty Bell, a close copy of Fey’s design, and shipped it across North America by the thousands — including into Canada, where the machines spread through hotels and clubs until provinces began banning them in the early twentieth century. Mills also gave the machines their fruit symbols and the BAR logo. He invented nothing fundamental. He just made it everywhere, which is why some older write-ups credit him anyway.
Fey’s grandson Marshall Fey, who spent decades restoring antique machines and literally wrote the book on the subject — Slot Machines: A Pictorial History of the First 100 Years — put the family’s case plainly:
“My grandfather’s Liberty Bell was the first machine to pay out coins automatically. Everything since is a variation on that idea.”
Strong words. Also, basically correct.
From cast iron to a Canadian phone screen
The reason this 130-year-old whodunit still matters is that Fey’s blueprint never really left. The game got electrified in the sixties, video-fied in the seventies, and dissolved into software in the nineties — but spin, resolve, pay remains the loop, whether the machine stands on a casino floor in Niagara Falls or runs in a browser in Moncton.
Canada’s own relationship with the descendants is its own layered story: slots arrived with Mills’ shipments, got banned, then returned legally through provincial casinos and lotteries — today Ontario alone runs a regulated iGaming market alongside OLG, while other provinces operate platforms like PlayNow and Espacejeux. And the modern catalogue dwarfs anything Fey imagined. The online slot games available to Canadian players on international casino platforms like LevelUp number in the thousands — and, in a detail that would delight an instrument-maker, each one publishes specs his cast-iron original never disclosed: the RTP percentage and volatility rating sit right in the info panel. Fey’s customers had to guess the odds. On LevelUp or any modern lobby, thirty seconds of reading tells you exactly what the long-run math is — typically 94–96% returned, the rest being the house edge that has funded this industry since a Bavarian mechanic first rented out his bell machine for half the take.
Which suggests the one piece of practical wisdom this whole history teaches: the machine has always kept a percentage. Fey’s did, Mills’ did, today’s software does. So the sane way to play — then, now, anywhere — is to treat it as paid entertainment, decide the ticket price before the first spin, and use the deposit-limit tools the modern versions offer.
So — who gets the credit?
My honest verdict after falling down this rabbit hole: Sittman and Pitt built the first popular coin-op gambling machine, Mills built the empire, but Charles Fey invented the slot machine — because the automatic payout is the invention, and that was his alone. A tubercular immigrant instrument-maker, sixteenth child of a Bavarian family, solved one mechanical problem in a San Francisco workshop, and 130 years later his three-reel logic is still spinning on phones from Victoria to St. John’s.
Not bad for a man who never even filed the patent.
This content is provided for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional advice. AFP editorial staff were not involved in the creation of this content. If you or someone you know is struggling with a gambling problem, a helpline is available at 1-888-532-3500.