Home A father writes about his daughter’s death by suicide: Don’t let the conversation end
Local

A father writes about his daughter’s death by suicide: Don’t let the conversation end

TW: suicide

suicide death mental health depression candle
Photo: © anandamrita/Adobe Stock

Carly Anne DeMille, just 13 years old, her whole life ahead of her, is, sadly, no longer with us; Carly died by suicide at her home in Timberville, in Rockingham County, on the evening of Wednesday, Nov. 11.

We wouldn’t normally report on a suicide, but her father, Austin Dean, doesn’t want the community conversation that has sprung up about his daughter’s tragic passing to end.

“Don’t let this conversation end when the social media posts stop appearing on your newsfeed. Don’t let it end when the community moves on to the next big headline. These are our children, the best things that have ever happened to us. If we allow this conversation to die, we risk failing another child. We risk losing another precious life,” Dean wrote in a heart-wrenching social media post about Carly, an eighth-grader at J. Frank Hillyard Middle School.



If you or someone you know needs support now, call or text 988 or chat at 988lifeline.org


Per her obituary, Carly was “a proud trombone player in the school’s band,” her obituary tells us, who “enjoyed drawing, anime, listening to indie music, playing soccer, and being with her friends and family.”

More from her obituary:

“There are people whose personalities are simply too big to be contained in a room, and Carly was one of them. She was funny in a way that made people laugh without even trying, beautiful in a way that went far beyond her appearance, and loving in a way that made the people closest to her feel special. She had a personality all her own, and anyone who knew her understood that there was never going to be another quite like her.”

The especially difficult part to this story: her parents, Austin and her mother, Riley, found out, after Carly had taken her life, that their daughter “had been struggling with being bullied,” which, dear god.

Just, dear god.

It’s tough enough to have to deal with the death of a young person from a car accident or a terminal disease.

Death resulting from middle-school bullying is entirely preventable.

A government website, StopBullying.gov, tells us that, “although most kids who are bullied do not experience suicidal thoughts or self-harm”:

“Kids who reported cyberbullying were 11.5 times more likely to present suicidal ideation, while individuals reporting verbal bullying were 8.4 times more likely.”

Translation: not all kids who are bullied think of suicide, but bullying can trigger suicidal ideation in some kids who have other things going on – like a pre-existing mental health condition, such as depression or anxiety, or are experiencing social isolation due to sexual or gender identity, or an adverse life event.

We didn’t have cyberbullying when I was growing up, just the verbal kind, but like a lot of you reading this will agree, that verbal kind, a generation ago, was at least as bad as it is today.

Which is to say, I know of this personally – and if we were to ask for a show of hands of those who felt pushed to the brink by bullying during our teen years, mine would go up.

I didn’t play the trombone or play soccer like Carly, mainly because, I wasn’t that talented as a kid, to be able to play a musical instrument, or a team sport, but I was teased relentlessly on the hour-long bus rides to and from my high school, the reason being, I got good grades in school, and passed the time on the bus reading books, which, yep, definitely would mark one as “different” – if only “different” was the worst of the words the kids who bullied me would have used.

It was hard some days – a lot of days – and it didn’t make it any easier that I was dealing with the fallout of childhood sexual abuse.

And that, after my parents’ divorce, my mom, raising us without my dad providing consistent financial support, could barely afford to keep the lights on, much less buy us new clothes for school.

Bullies are quick to jump on the poor kid with hand-me-downs afraid of their own shadow from sexual abuse who bury their heads in books hoping nobody will see them.

Was suicide something that came across my mind back then?

I’m not ashamed to say, it was, often.

Per StopBullying.gov, kids who are bullied are more likely to experience:

  • Depression and anxiety disorders, symptoms of borderline personality disorder, changes in sleep and eating patterns, and loss of interest in activities they used to enjoy, like sports teams and clubs.
  • Self-esteem issues with feelings of shame that can impact all aspects of kids’ lives.
  • Health complaints, including higher rates of headaches, stomachaches, and colds.
  • Behaviors, like increased rates of smoking, that increase the risk of future health concerns, like higher stress levels and sleeping problems.
  • Decreased academic achievement, like lower GPA, standardized test scores, and school participation. They are more likely to miss, skip, or drop out of school.

If you see any of these warning signs in your child, say something, do something, right away.

A generation ago, we were just expected to tough it out, whatever that was supposed to mean; now we know better.

Unfortunately, we’re reporting on this too late to be able to help Carly Anne DeMille through what she was having to endure on her own, but because of the braveness of her parents, maybe we can help prevent the next tragedy.

“Carly was a fighter,” her father wrote. “It’s heart-wrenching knowing that she was so much stronger than she ever could have realized. Her relentless spirit has helped carry us forward through the darkest time we have ever had to face. We know she’s here with us. We both feel her pushing us on. We will continue to fight like Carly, and spread the love and kindness she shared with everyone she met. Carly’s story is far from over. Carly is here to stay, and she will save lives.”

So, parents, Lesson #1 is, if you see your child struggling, consult the warning signs above, and do something.

Lesson #2 is for parents who are confronted with evidence that their child is engaging in bullying behavior.

StopBullying.gov tells us that “(w)hen adults respond quickly and consistently to bullying behavior they send the message that it is not acceptable. Research shows this can stop bullying behavior over time.”

That’s a good starting point right there.

Austin Dean hit to the heart of the matter with the observation that parents “need to take a good, hard look in the mirror” with regard to their behaviors, noting that “whether you realize it or not, your children are watching you.”

“When you make fun of someone, they learn that it’s acceptable,” Dean wrote. “When you exclude someone, they learn that some people are less deserving of friendship. When you criticize another child for being ‘different,’ you give your own children permission to do the same. When we allow that behavior to go unchecked, we help create an environment where some children feel like they don’t belong.”

Does anybody else reading along recognize the changes in society and popular culture over the past generation that have celebrities and politicians outright mocking some among us for being different, for looking different, for having to work harder to overcome physical, health or mental health, or developmental challenges?

We were thisclose to it being taboo to treat people the way we see TV and movie stars and people featured on the cable news treat people.

Which makes it hard for us to tell kids to straighten up their acts, when we don’t expect the same of famous people – or ourselves.

“We cannot continue to overlook the attitudes and behaviors we allow to develop within our own homes,” Dean wrote. “We cannot teach our children to only be kind to people who are just like them. We need to teach them to include the kid sitting alone. To approach the person who doesn’t have many friends and make an effort. To stand up for someone being picked on, even when it’s not popular. To understand that being ‘different’ is okay and doesn’t mean that something needs to be mocked or corrected.”

So, we’ve all got to clean up our own acts, and then, we have to hold our kids to account.

“If your child is the one doing the bullying, don’t make excuses for them,” Dean wrote. “Don’t play it off as kids being kids. Don’t defend their actions just because they are your child. Hold them accountable. Teach them better. Help them understand the consequences their words and actions can have on someone. Let them know that they don’t have to be friends with everybody, but they do have to treat everybody with dignity.”

We need to be able to say these things without waiting for a tragedy to shame us into having to take action, but here we are.

“We would give absolutely anything to have our sweet Carly back,” Austin Dean wrote. “Nothing will ever change what has happened to our family. But, if something positive can come from this tragedy, I hope that it’s that we become a community that does better. A community that raises children who lift each other up rather than tearing one another down. A community where being ‘different’ is okay. A community where every single child knows they have value, and they matter.

“Let’s do better for our children. All of them.”

 

Support AFP

Newsletter

Featured Video

 

 




Chris Graham

Chris Graham

Chris Graham is the founder and editor of Augusta Free Press. A 1994 alum of the University of Virginia, Chris is the author and co-author of seven books, including Poverty of Imagination, a memoir published in 2019. For his commentaries on news, sports and politics, go to his YouTube page, TikTok, BlueSky, or subscribe to his Street Knowledge podcast. Email Chris at [email protected]. Support AFP by signing up for our newsletter and/or powering our work with a one-time or monthly contribution.

Latest News

uva nov 13 graphic
Football, Go 'Hoos

The Nov. 13 Record: UVA alumni group sheds light on what the school knew

uva football kam robinson INT
Football, Go 'Hoos

ACC Football: UVA linebacker Kam Robinson among the Players of the Week

It’s been a while since a Virginia guy was among the ACC Football Players of the Week, so, congrats, Kam Robinson, who caught the attention of the select media panel with his picksix and 12 tackles in the 36-7 win over Cal on Saturday.

ncaa
Go 'Hoos, Sports

Women’s Soccer: Virginia to host Bryant in NCAA Tournament on Friday

Virginia, the ACC runner-up in 2026, is a two seed in the 2026 NCAA Women’s Soccer Tournament, and will host Bryant (7-6-5, RPI: 156), the America East champ, on Friday at 3 p.m. at Klöckner Stadium.

uva basketball thijs de ridder at the rim
Basketball, Go 'Hoos

UVA Basketball: What Virginia fans need to know about Old Dominion

bill belichick
Football, Go 'Hoos

First Look: What UVA Football fans need to know about North Carolina

wrestling
Pro Wrestling

WWE and AEW Power Rankings: Updated rankings post-AEW ‘Full Gear’

South River Greenway
Local

Waynesboro: Temporary closures this week on the South River Greenway