Home Arrest made in Augusta County church arson
Virginia

Arrest made in Augusta County church arson

Chris Graham

Special agents with the Virginia State Police Bureau of Criminal Investigation Appomattox Field Office arrested a Crimora man on Tuesday in connection with a fire at the Hildebrand Mennonite Church in Augusta County.

Paul L. Cupp, 36, of Crimora was arrested without incident at his residence on Meadow Rue Lane following the execution of a search warrant. Cupp is charged with one count of maliciously burning or destroying an unoccupied church by fire or explosives. He was transported to the Middle River Regional Jail in Verona.  The Augusta County Fire Department, Augusta County Sheriff’s Office and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms assisted with the arrest.

At approximately 10:47 p.m. on Saturday, a state police arson investigator was called to investigate a fire that took place at the Hildebrand Mennonite Church located in the 500 block of Hildebrand Church Road in northern Augusta County. A preliminary investigation showed the fire appeared to have started on the southwest side near the entrance to the church’s sanctuary. The church received superficial damage as a result. There were no injuries. The investigation remains on-going. At this time, there is no evidence linking this arson investigation to other fires in the area.

The joint efforts and cooperation between the Augusta County Fire Department, the Augusta County Sheriff’s Office, citizens in the community and the state police arson investigator resulted in the identification and arrest of a suspect.

“This investigation is an example of good teamwork and working collaboratively to establish probable cause for an arrest in this investigation,” says Lt. Joseph A. Rader, Special Agent-In-Charge of the Virginia State Police Appomattox Field Office. “Our investigator received valuable information from citizens in the community and stayed aggressive which produced positive results.”

Support AFP




Chris Graham

Chris Graham

Chris Graham is the founder and editor of Augusta Free Press. A 1994 alum of the University of Virginia, Chris is the author and co-author of seven books, including Poverty of Imagination, a memoir published in 2019. For his commentaries on news, sports and politics, go to his YouTube page, TikTok, BlueSky, or subscribe to Substack or his Street Knowledge podcast. Email Chris at [email protected].

Latest News

uva baseball chris pollard
Baseball

UVA Baseball: How are we supposed to feel about Chris Pollard throwing his guys under the bus?

tv
Etc.

AEW ‘Dynamite’ ratings back up post-Darby Allin nightmare title run

The weeks of decline in viewership for AEW “Dynamite” that coincided with the illogical move to put the world title on a skateboard goofball saw a reversal after the title switch at “Double or Nothing.”

matt augustin uva baseball
Baseball

UVA Baseball: RHP Matt Augustin among three ‘Hoos entering transfer portal

No surprise here, that Matt Augustin, a 6’3” righthander who was only used seven times in 2026 by the new UVA Baseball coaching staff, is in the transfer portal – one of three ‘Hoos to enter the portal on Monday.

lgbtq
Politics, Virginia

Marriage equality is the law of the land, sure, but, take nothing for granted

stephen colbert
Politics

Video: #TeamAFP plays the ‘Late Show with Stephen Colbert’ 15 questions game

government money
Politics, U.S. & World

Developing: Trump backing away from slush fund that Ben Cline had no problem with

matt hart uva basketball
Basketball

UVA Basketball: Ryan Odom names staffer Matt Hart to GM role