No criminal charges will be filed against police in the death of a Lynchburg man arrested on Christmas Eve as he was being apprehended in an assault case.
The case involving the death of Orlando T. Harding, 38, who died on Dec. 30 – the medical examiner ruled the death a homicide – was assigned to David Ledbetter, the Commonwealth’s Attorney in Waynesboro, in July.
Ledbetter, in a letter to Virginia State Police, the lead investigating agency, dated Nov. 13, declared that “the officers involved did not behave with criminal intent or reckless disregard for Harding’s life. Accordingly, the Waynesboro Commonwealth’s Attorney’s Office recommends that no criminal charges be brought.”
The letter from Ledbetter also details that officers had placed Harding in a “prone (face-down position” during his apprehension, and that in these scenarios:
“ … chest expansion and diaphragm movement may be restricted. This restriction can inhibit or prevent the person from exhaling carbon dioxide, potentially leading to cardiac arrest due to the buildup of lactic acid in the blood. Cardiac arrest in turn prevents oxygenated blood from reaching the brain, which can lead to a hypoxic brain injury.
“Mr. Harding’s medical providers from the Lynchburg General Hospital, which were provided as part of the investigative file, indicated that he experienced cardiac arrest associated with lactic acidosis. They opined that this in turn created a hypoxic ischemic brain injury leading to his death.”
A release from Virginia State Police tells us that officers at the scene used a Taser to incapacitate Harding, who continued to resist, “forcing officers to carry him to the police vehicle.”
“Officers also had to place Harding in leg shackles as he kicked at officers. Harding also made attempts to grab at the officers’ duty belts, including grabbing at their service weapons, and spit at the officers.
“Officers eventually removed Harding from the vehicle and placed him face down on the sidewalk as they awaited a spit covering, additional backup, and a different mode of transportation. Harding then stopped resisting.”
Details from Ledbetter’s letter tell us why Harding stopped resisting.
Harding was removed from the police vehicle and placed face down on the sidewalk at 12:29:59 p.m.
“At 12:31:10 PM, Officer Foster arrived on the scene and stated that officers needed to ‘make sure he’s awake and listening.’ Officers remained standing over and restraining Harding, but no officer at any time placed direct pressure on his neck or the thoracic area of his body.
“At 12:31:45 PM, officers noted that Harding was urinating. At 12:32:29 PM, Harding began vomiting. At 12:32:37 PM, officers rolled him over onto his side and called EMS. Harding appeared to become unresponsive shortly after this point, and officers requested a Code 3 (emergency) response for EMS.
“At approximately 12:33 PM, Harding can be heard on body-worn camera gagging and moaning. Believing his symptoms to be the effects of an overdose, Officer Frink administered a dose of Narcan to Harding at 12:33:18 PM. At 12:34:46 PM, Officer Frink administered a second dose of Narcan to Harding when the first did not appear to help. Sergeant Morris advised officers to roll Harding over and conducted sternum rubs on him to attempt to wake him up. She further stated that his pupils were completely dilated.
“EMS arrived and began administering aid at 12:39:30 PM. Harding was placed onto a stretcher. Sergeant Reed and Officer Willson adjusted Harding’s restraints so medics could perform chest compressions. Harding was then transported to Lynchburg General Hospital.”
Harding died at the hospital on Dec. 30.
The relevant sections of Ledbetter’s letter exonerating the actions of police involved in the detention:
“In the case at hand, Lynchburg Police Officers were responding to a report of a violent crime against a member of the general public, namely, an assault. The violent nature of the crime and the fact that the crime was committed against a member of the general public is evidence that Mr. Harding presented a danger to the community. His conduct towards the officers included kicking, spitting and reaching for their weapons, which demonstrated that he also posed an imminent safety risk to the officers. Throughout the interaction, Harding actively resisted the officers’ attempts to detain him, repeatedly sought to evade arrest including by fleeing, reaching for a weapon, and spitting on an officer. In response, the officers placed him in a position where he could be more easily controlled, posed less of a danger to the officers and the general community, and was less able to flee while waiting for further assistance by additional law enforcement officers. Given these circumstances confronted by the officers, they did not violate Harding’s constitutional rights by using excessive force.”
…
“(T)he officers attempted to mitigate the risks of placing him in the prone position by ensuring he was monitored while waiting for additional resources. Officer Foster stated that the officers needed to ‘make sure he’s awake and listening,’ and the officers continued to remain with him and monitor him. Once it became clear that Harding was experiencing a medical episode, he was turned on his side, and officers administered multiple rounds of Narcan under the belief Harding may be experiencing an overdose. Additionally, officers continued monitoring his vital signs including breathing, pulse, and responsiveness to verbal and physical stimuli. Accordingly, while the General Order states that officers should not leave handcuffed people laying face down, the multiple other positions they attempted being met with consistent combativeness from Harding combined with their attempt to mitigate the risks associated with the prone position indicate they did not act with a ‘reckless disregard’ for Harding’s life.”