With the Christmas holidays approaching, there’s a good chance the movie Miracle on 34th Street will be shown many times on your television screen.
And with it comes as a Virginia connection in the form of the late actor John Payne, who was born in Roanoke, also grew up in Salem and briefly attended Roanoke College before finding stardom in Hollywood via New York City.
Payne, in the 1947 classic, plays attorney Fred Gailey, who defends Kris Kringle. The Academy Film Archive preserved Miracle on 34th Street in 2009, and four years earlier the film was selected for preservation by the United States National Film Library of Congress as being “culturally, historically or aesthetically significant.”
But his lengthy career was not just a one-hit wonder.
“John Payne, an all-around actor who starred in nearly 50 films, mostly in the 1940s and ‘50s, died of a heart ailment” in California, wrote the New York Times for his obituary in 1989.
He had many roles in the film noir genre in the late 1940s and early 1950s. One of them was Kansas City Confidential, which the Salem Museum featured in August after a presentation there by assistant director Hunter Haskins.
In the presentation, Haskins noted that a daughter of Payne moved to the Roanoke area for a few years to run a restaurant before returning to California, most likely.
Star City star
So, where does Payne rank among famous Roanoke natives?
“I personally feel that he should rank pretty high, although much of his legacy has yet to be fully explored,” Haskins wrote to the AFP. “Without doubt there have been a few great, targeted explorations of Payne, some on his time in Hollywood and a few on his local ties, but it would be great one day to see a book-length treatment of Payne’s life and times. Without doubt, there’s a story there that needs to be told much louder than it is at the moment.”
Payne also appeared in Tennessee Partner in 1955 with Ronald Reagan, the future U.S. president.
That came 20 years after a big break in New York.
“In 1935, Payne got a part in a Broadway show starring Beatrice Lillie. His song and dance work for the musical comedy caught the eye of a Hollywood talent scout that helped launch Payne into a successful career in motion pictures. This came just one year later, with a motion picture entitled Dodsworth. Payne worked with most of the outstanding film stars of Hollywood’s golden years – the ‘30s and ‘40s. He produced and starred in Restless Gun, a western TV series which in 1958 reached nearly 30 million viewers,” according to the Roanoke College website.
Payne was born on May 23, 1912, in Roanoke to Ida Hope, who graduated from Virginia Seminary, and George Washington Payne, a local developer.
For a time, they lived at the Fort Lewis estate mansion, which was later destroyed by fire in 1949.
Payne attended Episcopal High in Alexandria and Mercersburg Academy in Pennsylvania before a brief stay at Roanoke College.
From there he went to Columbia and the Julliard School in New York in the 1930s. To make money on the side, Payne was a wrestler and boxer.
Payne left for Hollywood in 1936 and had several jobs in radio, as well as television and movies.
“Payne also did radio work,” according to the Roanoke College website. “He was star of the Restless Gun TV show, which he later ended his affiliation with because they supported cigarettes, something he did not support because of their direct cause of cancer. Payne also paid tribute to his alma mater in 1974 when he did a film interview for a TV show that talked about prominent alumni from Roanoke College.”
Payne survives scare
He was a guest star on the Ford Show with Tennessee Ernie Ford in 1957. Ford, who was born in Bristol, Tenn., passed in Reston in Northern Virginia in 1991 of liver failure after attending a state dinner at the White House hosted by President George Herbert Walker Bush.
Payne was hit by a car as a pedestrian in New York City in 1961 but recovered after several months.
His last TV appearance came in 1975 on a Columbo episode with Peter Falk and Janet Leigh called “Forgotten Lady.”
Through real estate investments, Payne became even more wealthy while working in Southern California.
Payne was married three times – sort of standard for Hollywood stars at the time.
His second wife was film star Gloria DeHaven, who died in Las Vegas at the age of 91 in 2016. His first wife was actress Anne Shirley, who passed at the age of 75 in 1993 in LA.
Payne’s last wife was Alexandra Crowell Curtis, who he married in 1953; she died at the age of 91, in her native LA in 2009.
Payne died in Malibu – 42 years after his defining role in Miracle on 34th Street.
Payne was awarded the Roanoke College Medal for his distinctive service and professional achievement.
“I was drawn to Payne as an undergraduate (at Roanoke) because I am a classic movie buff,” Haskins wrote. “So, I would watch an occasional flick of his now and then during my studies there (2017-2021), but my interest fell to the wayside after graduating and moving back down to Henry County. Life and work, as they say, got in the way.
“Flash forward to 2024, and I’m hired as the assistant director of the Salem Museum, and suddenly I have dozens of primary and secondary resources at hand to explore Payne and his legacy in the area and beyond. I had no idea how fascinating and extraordinary Payne truly was – in the worlds of creativity, business, and more, he really was an insightful and fascinating character. I’ve spent lots of time now watching his films.”