Augusta County realtor Amy Argenbright was found guilty of two counts of felony construction fraud Tuesday following a two-day trial and a two-week deliberation by Circuit Judge Shannon Sherrill.
Sherrill scheduled a sentencing hearing for Feb. 23, granting a request from defense attorney Thomas Weidner IV for a presentence report.
Outlining the basis for the verdict, Sherrill emphasized that criminal intent was the most critical element established during the trial. While noting that Argenbright’s financial records demonstrated ineptitude, the judge stated that fraudulent intent was also present, remarking that “both can be true.”
The convictions stem from two separate home-building agreements:
- The Burchett Project: Candy Burchett, a retired federal IT employee, advanced more than $245,000 to build a 1,700-square-foot home in the Valley Manor Subdivision west of Staunton. She was left with only an unfinished foundation and no lumber on-site, a condition Sherrill noted could easily be mistaken for an abandoned project by a casual observer.
- The Weigley Project: David Weigley advanced $366,000 for a home on Entry School Road in Augusta County. By the time Weigley issued a demand letter in October 2024, the property remained an incomplete shell lacking windows, drywall, and cabinets. Augusta County builder Kevin Lacey intervened at Weigley’s request. Finishing the house required an additional $428,000. To prevent Weigley from draining his retirement savings, Lacey loaned his friend $250,000 at 7% interest — a loan Weigley has since repaid.
Trial evidence revealed that advance payments were mismanaged and diverted from construction. Specifically, a nearly $52,000 advance provided by Weigley in June 2023 was used in part to cover Argenbright’s delinquent mortgage payments at First Bank & Trust rather than his home. A bank employee testified that the mortgage was seven months delinquent. Furthermore, large deposits from both victims were transferred from Argenbright’s business account into a personal account shared with her husband, Eric.
Sherrill described the situation as characterized by “a string of broken promises and obfuscation toward each victim,” concluding that Argenbright had falsely represented her solicitations for advances.
Following the ruling, Burchett expressed relief and asserted that Argenbright belongs in jail, urging supporters to review the evidence.
Weidner acknowledged the difficulty and sadness of the situation for all parties involved, including the victims, stating that his client simply “got in over her head.”
Argenbright, who remains free on bond, posted a statement following the verdict on her Facebook page, saying the verdict “may have just had a fire lit under my ass.”
“I have let Weidner know that I will be careful to hold my tongue but that I also make no promises. There is more to come. I found out a lot of things that were going on behind the scenes during the construction project,” Argenbright wrote
“Oh, and if you happen to be friends with or related to Kevin Lacey … unfriend me now!” Argenbright wrote.
From the archives
- Coverage of the Amy Argenbright fraud case: click here.