I admit that I was surprised by the Democrats’ Blue Wave earlier this month. I thought that Republican gerrymandering put Dems at a big disadvantage and at best they would barely get more than 50 percent of the House seats and perhaps one or two Senate seats. I couldn’t imagine Texas or Maine going blue. I’m so happy to be so wrong!
While the media pundits debate why Republicans lost so badly – the economy, data centers, the war with Iran, etc. – I believe in large part it was because Donald Trump encouraged people to vote as if he were on the ballot, and they did. Increasingly, Trump is viewed as a vulgarian, a man who is crude, nasty, and sexually inappropriate in his speech and behavior.
Trump’s MAGA base has always represented about a third of voters, and that hasn’t budged. But the third in the middle, that liked some of his ideas, such as closing the borders, couldn’t continue to put up with his stupidity and nastiness. And ultimately, they recognized that Republicans have allowed him to get away with this behavior.
The question now is whether Democrats can unite around the policies and actions they ran on and that Americans want addressed. By our votes, we want Democrats to be successful; the onus is now on them.
Although the blue wave was more of a ripple in Virginia’s Sixth District, it was nonetheless, the first time any challenger received as many votes as Beth Macy: 55 percent Ben Cline to 44.8 percent for Macy.
The numbers tell an interesting story. For example, in 2018, Cline received around 168,000 votes (59.7%) to Jennifer Lewis’ 113,000 (40.2%). That was the most any Democrat received in 20 years running against a Republican incumbent.
However, this year, Cline received 177,000 votes, a 5.3 percent increase over 2018, whereas Macy received 144,000 votes, a 27.4 percent increase over Lewis’ performance. And that is not all. In 2024, when Trump was on the ballot, 407,000 votes were cast in the Sixth District to just 321,000 in this year’s election, a 21 percent decrease in voter participation. That indicates that with the right campaign, there are a lot more people out there who will vote for a Democrat.
As I suggested in my earlier article, the Sixth District is becoming more urban and cosmopolitan, characteristics of a more liberal, blue voting population. That was evidenced by Waynesboro, which for the first time went Democratic. And Macy appears to have won every incorporated city in the district. Not too shabby.
For me, the most important thing Macy did was to go after Cline while still keeping the campaign civil. I think she did a good job of pointing out Cline’s malevolence, such as taking money from corporate donors who influence his votes, not making himself accessible to constituents, and most importantly not voting in the best interests of the Sixth District. Her campaign was also well organized, and she made good use of the media to get her message out to voters.
So, what’s next? When I interviewed her, I asked her that question, and she rightfully said she wasn’t thinking beyond this campaign. Like a fighter who prepares for a boxing match, her concentration and energy were focused on this election. By her tone, I wasn’t sure if she would be interested in stepping back into the maelstrom. However, like a boxer, one match does not determine the fighter’s future.
I encourage Macy to look across the state line to North Carolina’s Ninth District, which Donald Trump won by more than 10 points in 2024. This year, Democrat Richard Ojeda won, beating out the incumbent, Richard Hudson, the National Republican Congressional Committee chair. Also, not too shabby. Notably, Ojeda had lost a number of previous attempts at national office, but he wouldn’t and didn’t give up.
If we want to de-Cline the Sixth District in 2028, here is what must happen. First, Sixth District Democrats need to select a candidate within the next six months; no later than the spring of 2027. As I noted in my prior article, one of the greatest obstacles Democrats create for themselves is selecting their candidate in the late spring of an election year. That leaves just six months or so for the candidate to create an entire election support system from scratch.
Hopefully, that candidate will be Beth Macy, who now has name recognition, an organizational structure, and campaign experience. But if she chooses not to run again, then another candidate needs to be identified early to create the organization it takes to run a strong, well-funded campaign.
Second, the Democratic Party of Virginia needs to make turning the Sixth District blue a priority. Macy’s campaign was acknowledged as turning the Sixth District as a ‘district in play’. Gov. Spanberger, and Sens. Kaine and Warner, campaigned with her. That support cannot stop now that the election is over. Instead, the DPV should work with the candidate (hopefully Macy) to identify how that support can be even stronger and more effective.
Third, declaring one’s candidacy early provides the time to raise the millions of dollars contemporary political campaign now cost. Macy was able to get a few television ads produced and aired, but more television exposure might have helped even more.
Fourth, as I noted in my previous article, the candidate must think and function strategically. For example, the candidate needs to do a thorough analysis of the past campaign to identify strengths to build on and weaknesses to overcome. This might start with the candidate examining election results by ward and precinct to identify areas where greater effort is needed to get Democratic leaning voters to the polls. And it should include an assessment of media utilization to determine what forms of media, such as radio, television, and the web were most effective and where funding for media should be focused in the next campaign.
There are, of course, many other strategic actions that should be taken, but this last would fit a Macy campaign quite well and that is to continue running for office as if the election wasn’t over. For example, as the voice of the people, continue to travel across the district to meet with people and even hold town meetings, which would spotlight Cline’s lack of interaction with his constituents.
It would provide an opportunity to critique Cline’s voting record in real time and the impact that vote has on Sixth District constituents, whether for good or bad. For example, if he votes against expanding Medicare to children, as Democrats are now proposing, and Cline is surely to oppose, hit the radio and television circuit to criticize Cline’s position. If he votes against raising the contribution wealthy individuals make into Social Security, target seniors and explain why that vote could result in their losing benefits.
Athletic championships are not decided by one game. When a boxer loses a fight, the athlete typically takes some time to regroup and refocus and to assess why he/she lost. The same is true in politics. Like North Carolina’s Richard Ojeda, many Democrats who won this time had lost previous elections. For example, Ohio Sen. Sherrod Brown served from 2007 to 2025, when he lost to Republican Bernie Moreno. However, this year he ran for Ohio’s other Senate seat and won. Even Abraham Lincoln lost some of his early runs for office.
This hopefully will be an encouragement to Beth Macy and her team. It is understandable that after an emotionally, mentally and physically demanding campaign, Macy needs time for herself and her family. However, she can take pride in the race she fought and the results she attained. Nonetheless, we will never have a Democrat representing Virginia’s Sixth District if we pick a new candidate every two years and that candidate has to start from scratch each time.
As for me, I’m holding on to my MACY FOR CONGRESS yard sign and as soon as she gives the word, I’ll get out my Magic Marker, add 2028, and put it back out in my front yard.