There’s some hurry up and get this done politics being waged over the status of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, which the energy sector and the Trump administration want to see passed before the end of the year.
The bill – usually referred to by its acronym, BAAJA – would reduce the impact of messy environmental reviews and legal challenges on the buildout of energy infrastructure.
But what the developers view as red tape is viewed by environmental advocates as doing our homework.
This isn’t a simple the Trumpers want it, so it’s bad issue, though – the bill passed a procedural vote in the U.S. Senate this week by a healthy 65-34 majority, with one of our two Democrats from Virginia, Mark Warner, among the 65.
There’s certainly some bad and some good within the provisions.
The bad:
- the bill would give federal regulators the ability to overrule states on applications regarding new power lines.
- it would allow developers to sue governments over alleged disparate treatment of different energy sources.
- it would also expand the exemptions from environmental reviews.
The one good thing that I see is, preventing a new administration from blocking already approved energy projects, as we’ve seen the Trump administration try to do repeatedly with Biden era initiatives.
Even that one isn’t all good – just as the current Trump, or a future Trump, would be constrained, so would a Democratic president who would want to override dumb or even illegal stuff done by a certain predecessor.
That provision could, indeed, be an example of, be careful what you wish for.
Seems to me that we’re at the point where maybe this bill shouldn’t be rushed through in the lame-duck session of the current Congress, which only has a few weeks left, around the holidays, with a budget bill still being a top priority.
Good news on that: BAAJA is likely to fall victim to the calendar.
Even among those in the Senate who support the bill, there is demonstrated interest in making tweaks to the language that will add time to the final consideration.
And then, whatever version of BAAJA would emerge from that process would need to be approved without amendment in the House, where the support for the legislation isn’t as strong as it has been in the Senate.
Environmental advocates aren’t leaving things to chance, for good reason.
“We shouldn’t and don’t need to endanger our wildlife just to save a few dollars on gas,” said Lisa Frank, the executive director of Environment America, which is among the advocacy groups opposed to the bill.
“We shouldn’t and don’t need to weaken the rules that protect our water from pollution in order to build more clean energy. We shouldn’t facilitate more global-warming air pollution. And we definitely shouldn’t be taking away the public’s right to weigh in on projects that can ruin their environment, make them sick and lessen their quality of life,” Frank said.
“While permitting processes can be improved, speed should not be the only metric. A thorough review of impacts that protects individuals’ and states’ rights to mitigate consequential disruption is paramount. Now is the time to do the analysis and planning that moves us forward without avoidable and irreparable damage,” said Chris Miller, president of The Piedmont Environmental Council.
“Such transformational changes must be subject to more, not less, transparency, assessment, and mitigation to reduce harm,” Miller said. “It is time to pause and plan for the energy future, not rush to cut corners for speculative corporate gain and utility profits.”