Home ACLU of Virginia applauds attorney general opinion on ICE detainer requests

ACLU of Virginia applauds attorney general opinion on ICE detainer requests


acluAttorney General Mark Herring issued an opinion today concluding that Immigration & Customs Enforcement (ICE) detainer requests seek voluntary action by sheriffs, corrections staff, and jail authorities, and, as such, cannot be used to deny someone their liberty. The analysis and findings in the Attorney General’s opinion closely mirror those in a letter sent on July 31, 2014, by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Virginia to all Virginia sheriffs, regional jail officials, and state corrections officials.

The Attorney General found that “an ice detainer is merely a request and does not either impose a mandatory obligation or grant legal authority for a law enforcement agency to maintain custody of an individual who is otherwise subject to immediate release from local or state custody. A person has a constitutional liberty interest in not being imprisoned longer than he was sentenced by the sentencing court. Accordingly, an adult prisoner who is eligible for release from custody must be released at his eligible date notwithstanding the agency’s receipt of an ice detainer.”

“This opinion is neither pro-immigration nor anti-immigration,” said Claire Guthrie Gastañaga, Executive Director of the ACLU of Virginia. “It is simply about the Attorney General’s respect for the U.S. Constitution, due process, and the rule of law.”

“Refusing to release a person who has served his or her time and depriving that person of his or her liberty in the absence of probable cause is unconstitutional and can be costly to taxpayers,” Gastañaga added.

The ACLU of Virginia’ s letter to sheriffs, corrections staff, and jail authorities, urged these officials to change their policies and practices and deny any  ice detainer request not accompanied by a judicial finding of probable cause necessary to deprive someone of their liberty.  Today’s Attorney General opinion takes the same position.

“We applaud Attorney General Herring for his decisive action and for recognizing the critical importance of fostering trust between immigrant communities and local law enforcement,” said Joseph Montano, Immigrants’ Rights Coordinator at the ACLU of Virginia.  “Complying with every voluntary ice detainer request they receive, even where there is no evidence of criminal wrongdoing, undermines the trust between the public and law enforcement, making us all less safe,” Montano concluded.

The Attorney General’s opinion remains important even though the federal immigration enforcement program and use of detainers was changed recently by executive action.  This opinion makes clear that warrantless detainer requests can impinge on a person’s liberty in violation of due process.  Accordingly, any local, state or regional jail official who continues to honor any such warrantless request, as the Rockingham County sheriff declared he would, is now clearly on notice that such action is unconstitutional.



Have a guest column, letter to the editor, story idea or a news tip? Email editor Chris Graham at [email protected]. Subscribe to AFP podcasts on Apple PodcastsSpotifyPandora and YouTube.

Latest News

Baseball, Sports

Baseball: Virginia completes 3-0 weekend in Florida with 6-4 win over Auburn

Basketball, Sports

VCU overcomes sluggish first half, rallies past Saint Joseph’s, 73-69

VCU shot 72 percent in the second half to rally from a 27-21 halftime deficit on its way to a 73-69 win over Saint Joseph’s on Sunday at the Siegel Center.

preparing to bake a pie
Basketball, Sports

Scott German: How about that piece of Tony Bennett humble pie now?

After a dismal 76-60 loss at NC State in early January that saw Virginia fall to 2-2 in ACC play, I did the unthinkable, writing about the possibility of UVA coach Tony Bennett being near the finish line at his tenure in Charlottesville. 

coach mox
Basketball, Sports

Women’s Basketball: Virginia stuns #20 Louisville, 73-68, for third Top 25 win

uva bennett staff
Basketball, Sports

Bennett has the blueprint for how to fix his offense: He just doesn’t want to use it

ncaa tournament
Basketball, Sports

Metrics: Virginia continues to fall in computer rankings with another L

Cops & Courts, Virginia

Update: Virginia Tech student talks with authorities in Missouri, case considered closed