Home ‘You broke it, you own it’: Venezuela action will be judged by what happens next
Virginia

‘You broke it, you own it’: Venezuela action will be judged by what happens next

Crystal Graham
Venezuelan Venezuela flag protest unrest immigrant migrant TPS
Photo: © hendra – stock.adobe.com

What happens in the aftermath of the removal of Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro will ultimately determine how the the action is viewed by Americans and the world at large, according to a Virginia Tech political science professor.

“Justifiable concerns exist about the extent of coordination or planning for what would follow the attack, bringing to mind the so-called ‘Pottery Barn rule’ first coined by commentator Thomas Friedman: ‘You broke it, you own it,’” said Karen Hult, weighing in on the U.S. military’s capture. Colin Powell later used the phrase to warn the U.S. about invading Iraq.

Associate Professor Paul Avey also weighed in saying the move could worsen relations between the U.S. and Venezuela.

“Historically, the U.S. has faced challenges in turning successful military operations into sustainable political gains,” Avey said. “Some research finds that imposing a new regime more frequently damages than improves relations.”

Prior to the U.S. military action, Maduro allegedly agreed to make major economic concessions, Avey said, but refused to leave office.

“Achieving political objectives by replacing a leader requires that new leaders maintain stability and negotiate either because they share interests or they fear a similar fate,” Avey said.

The U.S. is hopeful Venezuelan Vice President Delcy Rodríguez, now the acting president, will be willing to make additional concessions.

“Yet they are also hedging their bets by maintaining military options if Rodríguez does not align with U.S. policy,” Avey said.


ICYMI


advertise with us 2025 U.S. President Donald Trump has said not ruled out additional military strikes and said he’s prepared to put U.S. troops on the ground if Rodríguez does not cooperate. While many Republicans have come out in support of the removal of Maduro, a few have contradicted the president, saying they do not want to see the U.S. deploy soldiers on the ground.

Five GOP senators joined their Democratic colleagues in a vote on a war powers resolution that would require the approval of Congress before any future strikes in Venezuela.

“While I support the operation to seize Nicolás Maduro, which was extraordinary in its precision and complexity, I do not support committing additional U.S. forces or entering into any long-term military involvement in Venezuela or Greenland without specific congressional authorization,” said U.S. Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine).

Even if the military action didn’t follow proper protocols, Hult said that similar incidents under previous administrations have had limited legal consequences.

“Actual presidential practice and judicial deference to elected officials, particularly presidents, in this instance and in similar U.S. military actions suggest the key concerns involve political and policy, rather than legal arguments,” she said.


 
 

 




Featured Video

 

Crystal Graham

Crystal Graham

A 1999 graduate of Virginia Tech, Crystal Graham has worked for 25 years as a reporter and editor for several Virginia publications, written a book, and garnered more than a dozen Virginia Press Association awards for writing and graphic design. She was the co-host of "Viewpoints," a weekly TV news show, and co-host of "Virginia Tonight," a nightly TV news show, both broadcast on PBS. Her work on "Virginia Tonight" earned her a national Telly award for excellence in television. You can reach her at [email protected]. Support AFP by signing up for our newsletter and/or powering our work with a one-time or monthly contribution.

Latest News

James Franklin Virginia Tech
Football

Was James Franklin really trying to complain about not having an airport nearby?

waynesboro map
Local

Waynesboro: School Board at critical juncture in search for new superintendent

The search for a new Waynesboro Public Schools superintendent is reportedly down to three finalists, with the goal of the Waynesboro School Board to have an announcement about the hire of a new superintendent by the end of the month.

westwood hills elementary school
Local

Westwood Hills community honored for heroism during Sept. 2 school shooting

Teachers, staff, first responders and community members who protected students and support families during and after the tragic events at Westwood Hills Elementary School on Sept. 2 were honored with a surprise Dawbarn Education Award at a ceremony on Wednesday night. Waynesboro Public Schools Superintendent Dr. Jeffrey Cassell accepted the award on behalf of the...

soccer
Go 'Hoos, Sports

Men’s Soccer: Virginia gets past Notre Dame on PKs, advances to ACC Quarterfinals

acc football
Football

ACC Football: Two big games in primetime on Friday, Saturday, this week

uva basketball team
Basketball, Go 'Hoos

UVA Basketball: ‘Hoos have work to do to clean things up after win in opener

callie schaeffer warren schaeffer
Baseball

Broadway, Virginia Tech grad had a Rocky Mountain summer with the Rockies