The State Corporation Commission staff is recommending that the three-member commission deny the proposed $67 billion merger of NextEra Energy and Dominion Energy.
The staff, on Monday, issued a 201-page report on its review of the merger, which was announced in May; the paperwork was filed with the SCC in July.
The combined company would have a market cap of $220.3 billion, which would make it the largest regulated electric utility on the planet, and overall, the third-largest company in the energy sector, behind fossil fuel giants Exxon Mobil and Chevron.
And it would position the two companies – NextEra is headquartered in Juno Beach, Fla., on Florida’s east coast, about 80 miles north of Miami; Dominion is headquartered in Richmond – to be the prime power supplier to the data center industry.
From the archives
- Coverage of the proposed NextEra-Dominion merger: click here.
The companies, feeling the heat with blowback to their proposed coupling, rolled out a pledge in September to extend monthly bill credits for four years, redirect credits that would have gone to data center operators, and expand low-income financial assistance by $100 million through 2038.
That’s all public and political, a small potatoes attempt to curry public favor.
The administrative viewpoint, from the SCC staff, is that “Petitioners have not met their burden to prove that ‘adequate service to the public at just and reasonable rates will not be impaired or jeopardized’ by the Merger,” per the executive summary to the staff report on the proposed merger.
The staff investigation tells us that “the proposed Merger would expose (Dominion) to the additional financial and business risks of NextEra’s unregulated, competitive businesses,” and that “the Merger Commitments and Supplemental Merger Commitments of the Petitioners are not sufficient to ensure that DEV will maintain the resources to provide adequate service to its customers post-Merger.”
“Given that Staff concludes the Petitioners have not met their burden under the statute, Staff concludes that the Merger as proposed in the Joint Petition should be denied by the Commission.”
Where this gets to be fun: the chair of the SCC, Kelsey A. Bagot, was a senior attorney at NextEra before her appointment in 2024, and Bagot has resisted pressure from lawmakers and public groups to recuse herself from voting on the proposed merger involving her recent former employer.