Home Commercial News Voir dire and jury selection: How attorneys identify favorable jurors

Voir dire and jury selection: How attorneys identify favorable jurors

legal case lawyer in court judge
Image © Gorodenkoff – Adobe Stock

Jury selection is part science and part intuition, but the attorneys who approach it systematically consistently do better than those who rely on gut instinct alone. Here’s how it works.

Voir dire, the process of questioning prospective jurors before trial, is one of the most underappreciated aspects of trial preparation. The jury that hears a case will determine the outcome, and yet many attorneys approach jury selection without a clear system for identifying which jurors are likely to be favorable and which are likely to be problematic. The difference between a well-executed and a careless voir dire can easily exceed any difference made by closing argument.

The goal of voir dire is not to find perfect jurors who will vote for your client. It’s to identify and remove jurors who are likely to be strongly unfavorable based on their attitudes, experiences, and biases, within the number of challenges available. Understanding who those jurors are requires asking the right questions and reading the answers carefully.

The purpose and structure of voir dire

Voir dire in most jurisdictions involves a combination of judge-conducted questioning and attorney-conducted questioning, with the specific allocation varying by court. Attorneys use peremptory challenges to remove jurors without stating a reason, and cause challenges to remove jurors who have demonstrated bias or inability to apply the law. Strategic use of both types of challenges, informed by systematic information gathered during questioning, is what separates effective jury selection from passive participation. Specialized trial support services can assist with developing voir dire questions and managing the information gathering process during selection.

The limited number of peremptory challenges in most jurisdictions, typically six to ten per side in civil cases, forces attorneys to prioritize. Identifying the most dangerous jurors and using challenges strategically to remove them, rather than using challenges based on hunches or surface characteristics, is the strategic challenge.

What jurors reveal in voir dire

Jurors who are openly biased against one party or issue are relatively easy to identify and challenge for cause. The more challenging task is identifying jurors who have attitudes and experiences that will influence their decision-making in ways that aren’t immediately apparent from their stated responses. Research on juror decision-making consistently shows that people often don’t accurately report their own biases, not because they’re dishonest but because they’re genuinely unaware of them.

Open-ended questions that invite jurors to talk about their experiences, values, and opinions reveal more than yes-or-no questions designed to confirm or deny bias. A juror who talks at length about how they distrust large corporations during a question about personal experiences with businesses is revealing something important. A juror who simply answers ‘no’ to ‘can you be fair to the corporate defendant?’ is revealing very little.

The role of attitudes in juror decision-making

Research in psychology and jury behavior consistently shows that jurors don’t decide cases purely on the evidence. They interpret evidence through the lens of their existing attitudes, values, and life experiences. A juror who has been injured by a defective product and received inadequate compensation will interpret the same evidence differently than one who believes the legal system is too generous to plaintiffs.

Understanding the attitudinal profile of the likely jury pool in a specific jurisdiction helps attorneys anticipate how case themes will be received and what kinds of arguments will resonate. Jurisdictions with strong plaintiff-oriented attitudes require different jury selection strategies than jurisdictions with skepticism toward litigation.

Systematic information management

Managing the information gathered during voir dire for twenty, thirty, or more potential jurors in real time is logistically demanding. Trial teams that have a system for recording and organizing juror responses, tracking which jurors said what, and cross-referencing responses with juror questionnaire information make better decisions than those trying to recall what each juror said from memory.

Seating charts that are updated as jurors respond, combined with numerical rating systems for tentative favorability assessments, provide a systematic basis for challenge decisions. When cause and peremptory challenges need to be decided quickly, having organized information rather than impressions is essential.

Using juror questionnaires

In complex cases, written juror questionnaires are submitted in advance of voir dire and allow jurors to provide detailed biographical, attitudinal, and experiential information in writing before court. These questionnaires, when the court approves them, dramatically increase the quality and quantity of information available about potential jurors and allow attorneys to prepare more targeted follow-up questions.

Questionnaires are particularly valuable for identifying experiences that are directly relevant to case themes: prior experience with the type of dispute, exposure to similar businesses or industries, family members in relevant professions, and prior litigation experience. These background factors often have predictive value for juror attitudes that isn’t captured by general demographic information.

Challenges for cause vs peremptory challenges

A challenge for cause succeeds when a juror has demonstrated actual bias or a legal disqualification. Courts have different thresholds for what constitutes sufficient bias for a cause challenge, and getting cause challenges granted requires eliciting clear admissions of bias on the record. Attorneys who are skilled at follow-up questioning that develops a clear record for cause can stretch their effective pool of removable jurors beyond the peremptory limit.

Peremptory challenges are exercises of discretion but are subject to Batson challenges that prohibit using them based on race or sex. The practical management of peremptories involves prioritizing the most dangerous identified jurors, being strategic about timing and sequencing, and being prepared to articulate race- and sex-neutral reasons for any challenge that might draw a Batson objection.

Wrapping up

Effective jury selection is a skill that develops over many trials and benefits from systematic preparation. Attorneys who develop comprehensive voir dire questions in advance, use organized information management during selection, and approach the process with a clear theory of who their most problematic jurors are make better selection decisions than those who improvise. On high-stakes cases, the investment in preparation for jury selection pays dividends throughout the trial.

Frequently asked questions

Can attorneys use social media to research potential jurors?

Yes, within limits. Attorneys are generally permitted to view publicly available social media profiles of potential jurors. Direct contact with jurors through social media or otherwise is prohibited. Passive observation of public profiles is permissible. Some courts and jurisdictions have issued guidance on this specific issue, and attorneys should be familiar with the rules in their jurisdiction. Social media research has become a standard part of juror research in jurisdictions where it’s permitted.

How accurate are attorney intuitions about juror favorability?

Research suggests attorney intuitions about juror favorability are somewhat better than chance but not nearly as reliable as attorneys typically believe them to be. Studies comparing attorney rankings of juror favorability to actual verdict outcomes show modest correlation at best. This is one reason systematic approaches, including pretrial juror research in significant cases, outperform purely intuition-based selection.

 

This content is provided for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional advice. AFP editorial staff were not involved in the creation of this content.

 

Support AFP

Newsletter

Featured Video