Home UVA Football: The conventional wisdom that led us to Tony Elliott is what’s to blame
Football, Go 'Hoos

UVA Football: The conventional wisdom that led us to Tony Elliott is what’s to blame

uva football tony elliott
Photo: Mike Ingalls/AFP

Tony Elliott was a solid hire, from the conventional wisdom perspective, when Carla Williams decided on him back in 2021, after she’d inadvertently run off the UVA Football coach that she’d inherited, Bronco Mendenhall, with an ultimatum on his staff.

The problem that we’re facing with UVA Football right now isn’t so much with Elliott, who is 26-30 in his fifth season, with one winning season to date, having been a reach of a hire, as it is with the conventional wisdom.

As the CW goes, both the people in college and NFL making the hiring decisions tend to overvalue the idea that, well, this guy is a good coordinator, so he will naturally just evolve into becoming a good head coach.

Problem being: the job of a head coach isn’t x’s and o’s.

Only a few head coaches at the top levels of the game are play-callers.

The job is more upper-level management than anything else – involving assembling a hierarchical staff, setting out the expectations for their performance, and at the college level, also overseeing the talent acquisition and retention process.

Your employees work under your thumb – the coordinators run offensive and defensive schemes that you approve, and develop game plans and call plays that fit the approach that you prefer.

But on gameday, they’re the ones calling the plays.

Technically, sure, the head coach can overrule a play call, but the limited time between plays means that doing so burns a timeout, of which you only get three for each half.

Back to Elliott, then, the conventional wisdom about him being the next good-to-great head coach was based on the assumption that, well, he won two national championships as a play-caller.

But had he ever had to hire a staff or been responsible for fleshing out a roster?

Hiring a guy without that level of managerial experience is obviously going to be hit-or-miss.

We may be, as Year 5 is winding down, finding out that Elliott was a miss – with the key failure with his style of management being, inability to adapt, most notably on offense, which is supposed to be where his x’s and o’s expertise should be a strength.

Problem there being, we hired a guy who was a good offensive play-caller to be the head coach, at which point he gave up the play-calling to become a manager, which requires an entirely different skill set.

In the next 12 months, UVA Athletics will be on the lookout, yet again, for a new head football coach.

curt cignetti
Curt Cignetti. Photo: David Rosenblum/Icon Sportswire

I would suggest, next time around, going the route that Indiana took when it hired Curt Cignetti away from JMU.

Cignetti had worked his way to JMU from D2-level Indiana University of Pennsylvania and FCS-level Elon, so, by the time he landed in Bloomington, he’d been a head coach for 13 years.

You’re just going to have more reliability out of a guy who isn’t learning on the job.

 

Support AFP

Newsletter

Featured Video

 

 




Chris Graham

Chris Graham

Chris Graham is the founder and editor of Augusta Free Press. A 1994 alum of the University of Virginia, Chris is the author and co-author of seven books, including Poverty of Imagination, a memoir published in 2019. For his commentaries on news, sports and politics, go to his YouTube page, TikTok, BlueSky, or subscribe to his Street Knowledge podcast. Email Chris at [email protected]. Support AFP by signing up for our newsletter and/or powering our work with a one-time or monthly contribution.