Home Cold case: Culpeper County mom’s brutal murder remains unsolved 20 years later
Virginia

Cold case: Culpeper County mom’s brutal murder remains unsolved 20 years later

Crystal Graham
cold case crime
(© blende11.photo – stock.adobe.com)

The brutal murder of Sheryl Warner took place 20 years ago in Culpeper County, and despite the lapse in time, investigators remain committed to finding the person responsible.

The Dec. 18, 2005, crime left three children without their mother and shocked the rural Virginia community.

According to police, Warner was alone in her residence on James Monroe Highway when someone knocked on her door asking to use her phone. Warner was on the telephone with her father and told him that the person wanted to call for help.

After she hung up, her family could not reach her again and called law enforcement.

When deputies arrived, they found Warner dead from a gunshot wound to the head. She had been hung in the basement, and according to investigators, her body had been set on fire.

With advanced technology, DNA has been developed in the case, but it is insufficient for an automatic computer comparison.

Detectives are asking the community for help solving the cold case.

“Regardless of how insignificant you think your information might be, or even if you think we already are aware of it, please let us assess the relevance of your tip,” said Culpeper County Sheriff Timothy Chilton.

“We remain committed to finding the person responsible for the brutal and senseless murder of Sheryl Warner.”

If anyone has information that may lead to the identification of a suspect, you are asked to contact the Culpeper County Sheriff’s Office at (540) 727-7900 or [email protected]

There is a financial reward for information that leads to the arrest and conviction of an offender(s).


Support AFP

Crystal Graham

Crystal Graham

A 1999 graduate of Virginia Tech, Crystal Graham has worked for 25 years as a reporter and editor for several Virginia publications, written a book, and garnered more than a dozen Virginia Press Association awards for writing and graphic design. She was the co-host of "Viewpoints," a weekly TV news show, and co-host of "Virginia Tonight," a nightly TV news show, both broadcast on PBS. Her work on "Virginia Tonight" earned her a national Telly award for excellence in television. You can reach her at [email protected]

Latest News

donald trump
Politics

Easier to die, harder to vote: The rigged architecture of the Warfare State

virginia tax
Virginia

State income tax filing deadline is Friday: Officials pushing you to file electronically

The filing and payment deadline for Virginia state income taxes is Friday, and Tax Commissioner Kristin Collins is saying it’s best at this stage to file electronically, if you can.

tony elliott gator bowl
Football

UVA Football: Finally, we have the details on Tony Elliott’s extension

UVA Football coach Tony Elliott got himself a million-dollar-a-year raise after his team’s 11-win season in 2025, with a total compensation package at $5.4 million a year, with $100,000 raises over each of the next five years of the deal.

uva football chandler morris
Football

UVA Football: Morris, Taylor among 10 ‘Hoos signing NFL rookie deals

football money
Football

UVA Football: Details on fresh extensions for Kitchings, Rudzinski, Gaither

rob tracinski podcast
Politics, Virginia

Podcast: Rob Tracinski discusses his Sixth District congressional campaign

ryan odom uva basketball
Basketball

UVA Basketball: Odom lands first transfer commitment for 2026 class