Home Augusta County: Judge to issue verdict in Amy Argenbright fraud case on Nov. 10
Local

Augusta County: Judge to issue verdict in Amy Argenbright fraud case on Nov. 10

Bob Stuart
amy argenbright mugshot construction fraud acso
Amy Argenbright. Photo: Augusta County Sheriff’s Office

The legal fate of Augusta County realtor Amy Argenbright remains in limbo following a two-day felony construction fraud trial. At the conclusion of arguments Wednesday, Circuit Judge Shannon Sherrill delayed rendering a verdict until Nov. 10.

The judge told the prosecution and defense he needs time to thoroughly review the trial evidence and more than 60 exhibits presented by both sides.

Argenbright actively assisted with her defense over the two-day trial. But she did not take the witness stand.

Along with his final verdict, Sherrill will decide on a defense motion to strike both charges, raised by Argenbright’s attorney, Thomas Weidner IV, who contended that the prosecution failed to prove the fraudulent intent necessary to sustain felony convictions.


From the archives

  • Coverage of the Amy Argenbright fraud case: click here.

The trial centered on two distinct home construction projects in Augusta County, beginning with a partial build of a home for David Weigley on Entry School Road.

Weidner insisted that the conflict with Weigley was strictly a civil matter rather than a criminal offense. Although Weigley had invested more than $366,000 in a house that remained far from complete, the defense argued there was no criminal abandonment.

The home was subsequently completed by a local builder, Kevin Lacey, for an additional $428,000.

Instead, Weidner asserted that work was actively taking place when “no trespassing” signs were posted and Argenbright’s company was abruptly ordered off the Entry School Road property in October 2024. He pointed out that a crew was on-site at the time and suggested the project was stalled primarily because Weigley had failed to provide the necessary electrical service to the build site.

Taking the stand in his wife’s defense, Eric Argenbright testified that he holds a Class A contractor’s license and has successfully completed homes throughout his career.

“I have built hundreds and hundreds of homes and never walked away. I’ve always finished,’’ he testified.

He told the court he was actively working on custom cabinets for the house when he and his crew were barred from the site. Eric Argenbright said he still has the cabinets, which were designed only for the Weigley home.

Under cross-examination by Assistant Augusta County Commonwealth’s Attorney Caleb Kramer, Eric Argenbright noted that while he managed the job sites and subcontractors, his wife handled all of the company’s financial affairs.

Kramer sharply contested the defense’s characterization, arguing that Amy Argenbright repeatedly solicited payments from Weigley under the pretense of purchasing essential building supplies.

Kramer introduced bank records showing that after Weigley made a payment of nearly $52,000 on June 15, 2023, over $19,000 was immediately transferred to First Bank & Trust to cover delinquent personal mortgage payments.

“There were no doors, no trusses,’’ Kramer said of materials needed to finish the Weigley home. “The money was applied to delinquent loans.”

First Bank branch manager Rebecca Poole verified that the Argenbright mortgage had been seven months past due prior to receiving those funds. Kramer argued that diverting client payments away from construction materials to cover personal debts demonstrated a clear pattern of fraudulent intent.

The second felony count focused on Candy Burchett, who paid more than $245,000 for a planned three-bedroom home in the Valley Manor Subdivision west of Staunton. Despite paying a substantial amount, Burchett was ultimately left with much less than a finished house.

The defense presented no evidence or witnesses to refute the charge. While Sherrill refrained from making an immediate ruling on guilt, he made it clear what he perceived.

“She (Burchett) paid a quarter of a million dollars and wound up with three foundation walls,’’ he said. The judge said there was only a footprint, not the 1,700-square-foot house Burchett was promised.

 

Support AFP

Newsletter

Featured Video

 

 




Bob Stuart

Bob Stuart

Bob Stuart has spent nearly four decades covering news and sports in Virginia and South Carolina, including 28 years at The News Virginian in Waynesboro. Stuart has focused on politics, religion, education, courts and police stories. He has been honored by the Virginia Press Association and South Carolina Press Association for his work. He is a graduate of the University of Richmond.