Longtime Augusta County realtor Amy Argenbright went on trial Tuesday in Augusta County Circuit Court on two counts of felony construction fraud, facing a maximum penalty of 40 years in prison if convicted.
Argenbright’s guilt or innocence will be decided by Circuit Judge Shannon Sherrill. Prosecutors dropped a third charge against Argenbright before proceeding to trial on the remaining two.
Testimony from both alleged victims revealed a common thread: both simply wanted to retire in the Shenandoah Valley. One sought an escape from Northern Virginia, while the other dreamed of building a home next to his daughter — a place his ailing wife could enjoy while battling Stage 3 cancer. She died before the home was finished by another contractor.
Tuesday’s testimony centered on missed construction deadlines, constant pleas by Argenbright for money because she lacked the resources to finish the two homes, and a loss of $245,000 for a home that was never built.
Assistant Augusta County Commonwealth’s Attorney Caleb Kramer told Sherrill he must prove Argenbright acted with fraudulent intent. Defense attorney Thomas Weidner IV argued there was no fraud, characterizing the charges as civil matters rather than criminal.
A dream home never built
Candy Burchett, an IT employee for the Marine Corps, selected the Valley Manor Subdivision west of Staunton as her retirement destination. In June 2024, she signed a $523,000 contract with Argenbright’s firm, A&Co 2002 LLC, for a 1,700-square-foot home with an expected completion date of March 15, 2025. The home would have three bedrooms and two baths.
Over the following months, Burchett testified that she made installment payments for portions of the home, including a finished basement, siding, a roof and excavation.
As the completion date approached, Argenbright repeatedly cited tight finances. “She told me daily or every other day there would be ‘no more surprises,’” Burchett testified.
After a final payment, Argenbright was given a 90-day extension to finish the work. By August 2025, updates stopped.
“The framing was supposed to begin, but it did not, despite promises,” Burchett said.
When she drove down from Stafford County to inspect the site in September and October 2025, she found only a foundation and a vacant lot. Burchett hired Staunton attorneys and sent a demand letter to Argenbright, but the house was never built. She testified she paid $245,013.50 to Argenbright and received no refund.
“I’m frustrated the house was never built,” Burchett said. “I expected normal delays. All I wanted was a house I never got.”
A place next door to his daughter
David Weigley owned a 20-acre lot on Entry School Road in Augusta County while living in Maryland.
“It was a place to move when retired and be close to my daughter,” Weigley testified. He signed a $518,000 contract in May 2023 for a home scheduled for completion by mid-to-late March 2024.
With his wife battling cancer, time was critical for Weigley, who wanted to settle in Augusta County while she was still alive.
What followed was a significant financial investment for a house that was left unfinished. Month by month, Weigley recounted missed deliveries and deadlines. By March 2024, framing was discussed but not completed. By May 2024, shingles arrived at the site, but windows did not.
“Where are they?” Weigley asked Argenbright about windows. He noted water was accumulating inside the open structure.
By August 2024, Weigley said he had paid $366,306.38 for a house lacking insulation, countertops and drywall. After a friend raised concerns about the property’s condition, Weigley filed a complaint with the Augusta County Sheriff’s Office. Investigator Chris Hilliard advised him to send a demand letter. By October 2024, Weigley posted trespassing signs and told Argenbright to stay off the property.
Augusta County builder Kevin Lacey intervened after inspecting the property in September 2024.
“The house was a shell. The wood was starting to deteriorate. There were no windows, and tarps were being used,” Lacey testified, noting the structure also lacked cabinets and drywall.
Lacey and his crew spent months finishing the work. The effort required an additional $428,000. To prevent Weigley from draining his retirement savings, Lacey loaned his friend $250,000 at 7% interest — a loan Weigley has since repaid.
Weigley expressed disappointment about the experience.
“We thought the builder would take care of us,’’ he said. When asked why he continued to make payments to Argenbright for work not finished, he said, “she requested them (payments).”
After Lacey’s intervention, Weigley now lives in the completed Entry School Road home. He moved in the house in August 2025, several months after his wife’s death.
The trial continues Wednesday. The prosecution will present a witness and finish its case in the morning. The defense will follow.