Home Commercial News Can you still sue if you’re mostly at fault in Wisconsin?

Can you still sue if you’re mostly at fault in Wisconsin?

sleet snow freezing rain road
(© sirisakboakaew – stock.adobe.com)

A winter crash on a Green Bay bridge deck often involves more than one mistake. One driver is sometimes going too fast for the ice. Another sometimes followed too closely. Wisconsin does not treat that mix as an all-or-nothing contest, but it also does not ignore your share of the fault.

You still have a claim if your share of fault is no higher than the share assigned to the person you are suing. Your damages are then reduced by your percentage. Here’s how that comparison works, who pays the full judgment, and why a death claim from a motor-vehicle crash has a shorter clock than an ordinary injury suit.

When does your own fault block the claim?

Section 895.045(1) provides that your own negligence does not, by itself, block a recovery for death or for injury to a person or to property, so long as your share of fault is no higher than the share assigned to the person being sued. Any damages that are allowed are then reduced in proportion to the share of negligence assigned to the person recovering. Your negligence is compared, one at a time, against each person found to have been a cause of the harm.

A plaintiff at 40 percent against one defendant at 60 percent still has a claim against that defendant. The same plaintiff at 60 percent against a different defendant at 40 percent is already barred as to that second person. After a Green Bay crash, Green Bay car accident attorneys at Gruber Law are one resource families use to sort out both that comparison and the filing clocks that run while it is being prepared.

The 51 percent cutoff

Section 895.045 also sets a second cutoff at 51 percent. A person found to have been a cause of the harm, and whose share of causal negligence is under 51 percent, is liable only for that person’s own share. A person whose share is 51 percent or higher is liable, together with others and individually, for the full amount of the damages allowed.

That 51-percent line is a separate rule from the “not greater than” comparison in 895.045(1), which already bars you if your fault is found greater than the defendant’s. You still lose against one driver and still have a claim against another. The comparison is made person by person, not as a single pile of blame.

Who pays the whole judgment?

The 51-percent rule in 895.045 decides who is made to pay the entire allowed judgment, not just a slice. A defendant with 40 percent causal negligence pays 40 percent. A defendant at 51 percent or more is held for the full allowed amount, subject to contribution later.

That difference matters when one at-fault driver has little insurance, and another has more. If you are collecting a judgment, the 51-percent defendant is on the hook for the whole allowed figure. The smaller-share defendant pays only that part.

The 3-year and 2-year filing clocks

Section 893.54(1m) generally requires a suit for personal injury, including a motor-vehicle crash, and a death caused by another person’s wrongful act, neglect, or default, to be started within 3 years, except as 893.54(2m) provides. Under 893.54(2m), a death claim that arises from a motor-vehicle crash has to be started within 2 years from the date the claim first arises. That 2-year window is the exception, not the default.

Other death claims still follow the 3 years in 893.54(1m). That difference is easy to miss if you assume every death claim runs three years. Those clocks still run while the percentages are being prepared.

Concerted action is a separate rule

If two or more parties follow a shared scheme or plan, each of them is liable, together and individually, for all damage that flows from that conduct, except as 895.043(5) provides. That concerted-action rule in 895.045(2) is not the same as the 51-percent cutoff. It applies to people who acted together under a common plan, even if a later comparison would have cut one of them off.

Under 895.045(1), a plaintiff whose share of fault is higher than the defendant’s is barred from recovering against that person. That finding ends the claim even if the winter road was plowed poorly. If you have ever watched a messy morning commute on Interstate 81 turn into a multi-car pileup, you already know more than one driver’s decisions are often in play, and the comparison is person by person.

Check the percentages and the filing date before you assume the case is over. A 40-percent share still leaves a claim. A 60-percent share against that defendant does not, and a motor-vehicle death claim has only two years.

 

This content is provided for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional advice. AFP editorial staff were not involved in the creation of this content.

 

Support AFP

Newsletter

Featured Video