Home Raj Date | Establishing minimum standards for the safety of financial products
Sports

Raj Date | Establishing minimum standards for the safety of financial products

AFP

Given the urgency and severity of the financial crisis, it is not surprising that most policymakers have to date been focused on here-and-now tactical initiatives to stabilize the financial system, rather than laying the foundation for a more sound and better regulated system in the future. 

There are exceptions; Sen. Durbin’s proposal for a Financial Product Safety Commission is one of them. The proposed commission would establish minimum standards for the safety of financial products, and would focus especially on identifying deceptive and fraudulent practices. The institution’s mandate would be analogous to the Consumer Product Safety Commission. As the proposal’s sponsors argued to the Treasury Secretary in a recent letter, “there is no reason for us to have regulations that prevent toasters from exploding into flames, but no protections to prevent mortgages and credit cards from doing the same.”

Opponents, thus far, have mustered what seems a half-hearted and formulaic argument against the proposal: introducing a new bureaucracy as the ultimate arbiter of product safety would effectively iron out differences in product structures and pricing, and dampen innovation.

The opposite is true. We have minimum standards on practically every consumer product – from automobiles to the aforementioned toasters – but innovation appears to proceed apace. You would be surprised what toasters can do these days!

Minimum product standards, then, don’t necessarily crowd out innovation. Instead, the difficulty for principled innovators in consumer financial services has been engineering new, improved product structures that can economically match the value captured through questionable, customer-unfriendly practices engaged in by competitors. Take the prime credit card business, for example. It is difficult to compete with large incumbents willing and able to use zero percent teaser rates, coupled with hair-trigger universal default repricing. The economic value of that customer-unfriendly practice was a killer advantage which stifled the need or potential for innovation.

A more persuasive objection to the proposed commission is that it would add to the existing thicket of state and federal financial regulators, rather than replacing them. By doing so it would create further administrative hoop-jumping and destructive friction on innovation.

The proposed commission avoids the political complexity of reducing an incumbent institution’s authority; but the fact remains that some regulators are dreadful when it comes to consumer protection. It was not by accident that Countrywide decided to re-charter its depository away from the OCC when the Fed and OCC began raising consumer protection concerns about non-traditional mortgage structures.

In reality, the industry suffers from too many regulators not from too much regulation. The proposed commission should pre-empt them – or, at least, it should pre-empt other federal authorities on these issues. The result would be more clarity, less arbitrage, and fewer burdens.

The proposal could be improved with an expansion of its mission from merely setting minimum standards. It is certainly true that deceptive sales practices are a major problem in consumer financial services, but they aren’t the main problem.

The main problem is that consumers – who, as it turns out, are human beings – are, in general, incapable of adequately weighing abstract financial risks and rewards. Perhaps the most telling example is banks’ “free checking” offerings, which aren’t free at all, because they tend to generate significant fees through non-sufficient funds (“NSF”) penalties on overdrafts. Consumers are aware of NSF fees; they just systematically underestimate how often they will incur them.

This is where the proposed commission could help. Let me suggest an analogy. Restaurants in Los Angeles County are required to post a large placard in their front windows, showing an “A”, “B”, or “C”. Those letter grades correspond to an establishment’s scoring in routine health department inspections. The Los Angeles approach made more transparent the hygienic disparity between restaurants. That is, it helps consumers understand that while many restaurants meet minimum standards, they are not all equally safe.

Using this approach with financial products would allow the Commission to encourage and reward especially consumer-friendly product structures, while not ironing out innovative product wrinkles. This is the outcome that we should all desire.

 

Raj Date is the chairman and executive director of the Cambridge Winter Center for Financial Institutions Policy. He is a former McKinsey & Company consultant, bank senior executive, and Wall Street managing director.

 

Support AFP

Newsletter

Featured Video

 

 




AFP

AFP

Have a guest column, letter to the editor, story idea or a news tip? Email editor Chris Graham at [email protected]. Subscribe to AFP podcasts on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Pandora and YouTube. Support AFP by signing up for our newsletter and/or powering our work with a one-time or monthly contribution.

Latest News

uva nov 13 graphic
Football, Go 'Hoos

The Nov. 13 Record: UVA alumni group sheds light on what the school knew

uva football kam robinson INT
Football, Go 'Hoos

ACC Football: UVA linebacker Kam Robinson among the Players of the Week

It’s been a while since a Virginia guy was among the ACC Football Players of the Week, so, congrats, Kam Robinson, who caught the attention of the select media panel with his picksix and 12 tackles in the 36-7 win over Cal on Saturday.

ncaa
Go 'Hoos, Sports

Women’s Soccer: Virginia to host Bryant in NCAA Tournament on Friday

Virginia, the ACC runner-up in 2026, is a two seed in the 2026 NCAA Women’s Soccer Tournament, and will host Bryant (7-6-5, RPI: 156), the America East champ, on Friday at 3 p.m. at Klöckner Stadium.

uva basketball thijs de ridder at the rim
Basketball, Go 'Hoos

UVA Basketball: What Virginia fans need to know about Old Dominion

bill belichick
Football, Go 'Hoos

First Look: What UVA Football fans need to know about North Carolina

wrestling
Pro Wrestling

WWE and AEW Power Rankings: Updated rankings post-AEW ‘Full Gear’

South River Greenway
Local

Waynesboro: Temporary closures this week on the South River Greenway