Home ACLU seeks dismissal of defamation suit intended to silence critics of monument protectionists
News and Views

ACLU seeks dismissal of defamation suit intended to silence critics of monument protectionists

AFP

aclu virginiaThe ACLU is seeking the dismissal of a defamation lawsuit against a UVA professor who spoke out through the news media about local issues involving the history of slavery in Charlottesville and their relationship to Confederate monuments.

Dr. Jalane Schmidt, historian, activist and associate professor of religious studies at UVA, is being sued by Charlottesville resident Edward Dickinson Tayloe II for a comment published in a March 6 C-Ville Weekly article about local figures fighting the Charlottesville City Council’s efforts to remove Confederate monuments there.

Her comment referenced Tayloe’s involvement in protecting the Confederate symbols and his family’s history of slave ownership and domestic slave trade.

“As a public historian, being able to give accurate historical context regarding current events is crucial. That is why I am working with the ACLU to defend my right to free speech,” Schmidt states.

Tayloe’s defamation lawsuit, filed May 28, accuses Dr. Schmidt, C-Ville Holdings LLC, and C-Ville Weekly reporter Lisa Provence of defamation and seeks nearly $2 million in damages.

In Dr. Schmidt’s response, the ACLU of Virginia argues that Tayloe is a limited public figure subject to criticism as a result of having interjected himself into the public monument debate. Further, her comment is an opinion protected by the First Amendment, and Tayloe failed to show that she made her comment with actual malice, which is a legal standard for defamation.

“Under the guise of an action for defamation, [Tayloe] seeks to censor the opinion of those who question both his support for the Confederate statues and his motivations for defending them,” the ACLU-VA’s filing states. Tayloe’s lawsuit sends “a clear message to others who wish to opine on matters of public concern in which Plaintiff is involved: disagree or critique Plaintiff Tayloe, then you, too, will face the threat of a lawsuit, including extraordinary financial liability and attorney’s fees.”

In asking the judge to dismiss the claim, the ACLU-VA characterizes it as a “strategic lawsuit against public participation (SLAPP)” suit, which is litigation intended to silence, censor and intimidate critics out of the marketplace of ideas by burdening them with the cost of a lawsuit they may not be able to afford.

 

Support AFP

Newsletter

Featured Video

 

 




AFP

AFP

Have a guest column, letter to the editor, story idea or a news tip? Email editor Chris Graham at [email protected]. Subscribe to AFP podcasts on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Pandora and YouTube. Support AFP by signing up for our newsletter and/or powering our work with a one-time or monthly contribution.

Latest News

ben cline
Politics, Virginia

Update: Ben Cline announces more town halls, with more waitlists

National Christmas Tree
Local

Highland County red spruce selected to serve as National Christmas Tree

A tree from the mountains of Highland County has been selected to serve as the National Christmas Tree, for display on the mess that serves as the White House grounds, with construction going on everywhere because our president wants to build monuments to himself.

school bus arm
Local

Albemarle County schools closed because of another major administrative screwup

More than 500 people hired in the past three years to work for Albemarle County Public Schools were not checked against the Child Protective Services Central Registry.

newspaper online news AFP mobile phone newsfeed
Local

AFP needs to do more: Just warning you, we’re going to ask for your help to get there

uva central grounds
Football, Go 'Hoos

Conservative alums lead the fight to hold UVA accountable for the failures of Nov. 13

mobile games casino phone computer
Politics, Virginia

State AGs pushing Trump FCC to take real steps to get rid of annoying robocalls

uva basketball thijs de ridder
Basketball, Go 'Hoos

UVA Basketball: NBA-like early schedule, tempo, defense, Gertrude/de Ridder