Virginia Supreme Court affirms ruling in lesbian-custody case

Item by Chris Graham
[email protected]

The Virginia Supreme Court today affirmed an appeals-court ruling granting a woman full visitation rights to the daughter that she had been raising with her former lesbian partner.

The decision in the Jenkins v. Miller case also affirms that federal and state laws governing child-custody disputes apply equally to gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender families in Virginia, civil-rights advocates said this morning.

“Most importantly,” said Dyana Mason, executive director of Equality Virginia, a Richmond-based civil-rights organizatin, “this common-sense decision means that the child involved in the dispute will have the love and support of both her parents as she grows up.”

Janet Jenkins and Lisa Miller entered into a civil union in Vermont in 2000. A daughter was born to the couple in 2002. Lisa Miller was the biological mother of the girl. The couple ended their relationship in 2003, and asked a Vermont court to dissolve their civil union and deal with issues related to the custody and visitation of their daughter.

In 2004, Miller filed a court action in Winchester asking that she be declared the sole parent of the girl, cutting off Jenkins’ visitation rights. The circuit court initially agreed and granted Miller sole custody of the girl, but the Virginia Court of Appeals reversed that decision on the basis of requirements in the U.S. Constitution that full faith and credit had to be given by the Virginia court to the earlier ruling in Vermont.

“This decision is fully consistent with Virginia, Vermont and federal law relating to child-custody disputes, and respects the requirements of the U.S. Constitution’s Full Faith and Credit Clause. The decision means that gay and lesbian parents can expect they will be treated just like any other parents in a custody dispute, regardless of their sexual orientation,” said Joseph R. Price of Arent Fox LLP, Washington, the lead attorney in the case representing Janet Jenkins.

“We are very pleased with the Supreme Court’s decision,” said ACLU of Virginia executive director Kent Willis. “It’s taken far too long, but we hope this will be the last stop in Janet’s pursuit to confirm her visitation rights.”

“The Virginia courts are simply following the accepted law and recognizing the custody and visitation decisions of another state, as it would expect other states to recognize its decisions,” said ACLU of Virginia legal director Rebecca Glenberg. “Lisa Miller-Jenkins does not get to cherry pick her courts to suit her liking. Simply because she did not like the Vermont court’s decision, does not allow her to try to get a more favorable ruling from another state.”